baymad4her

Borderline (Official Remixes & Different Versions)

Recommended Posts

I know this has been on another thread before and there was a lot of confusion over the versions so I really want to try and get this sorted because obviously I want them all, here's what I know/think, any help would be appreciated.

 

   

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

I know this has been on another thread before and there was a lot of confusion over the versions so I really want to try and get this sorted because obviously I want them all, here's what I know/think, any help would be appreciated.

 

      1. Album Version/Madonna (5:16) 
   
      2. Album Version/The Immaculate Collection – QSound Mix (4:00)
     
      3. Album Version/Celebration (4:00)
          (It was established this was a different mix to The Immaculate Collection version)
     
      4. Edit (3:58) (It's That Girl Cassette) (Edit of New Mix)      
          (This one I'm confused about, apparently it's the identical to the Japanese CD Single Collection, but is it also the                 same as: Remix Edit/Edit (Radio Version) (3:56) 
           even though it's listed separately on Remixology?)
 
      5. Remix Edit/Edit (Radio Version) (3:56)
          (See above?)
 
      6. Edit (3:59) (CD Single Collection) 
          (Is this Identical to It's That Girl Cassette but different mastering)??
 
    16. Video Version (3:56) (The Immaculate Collection DVD) (Celebration DVD)
          (Is this version the same as: Remix Edit/Edit (Radio Version)

 

6. Edit and 16. Video Version are identical. It's indeed the version that appears on the CD Single Collection.

 

4. Edit (3:58) (It's That Girl Cassette) (Edit of New Mix) is nearly the same as 6. Edit except that it has a few more echoes and audio effects. Technically closer to the New Mix thanks to those effects.

 

5. Remix Edit/Edit (Radio Version) is the same as 4., isn't it? I've never heard of one more mix.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Trying to give you some help here : 

          

      4. Edit (3:58) (It's That Girl Cassette) (Edit of New Mix)      
  => Not the same as the Japanese CD Single Collection. It is a unique mix. 
 
      5. Remix Edit/Edit (Radio Version) (3:56)
 => to me this one is the real 7'' version. From the japanese box.
 
      6. Edit (3:59) (CD Single Collection) 
  => I don't see where is this from.
 
      7. Fade (3:59)
 => from brazilian 7''
 
 
    16. Video Version (3:56) (The Immaculate Collection DVD) (Celebration DVD)
=> To me it's the same as 5

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

I know this has been on another thread before and there was a lot of confusion over the versions so I really want to try and get this sorted because obviously I want them all, here's what I know/think, any help would be appreciated.

 

1. Album Version/Madonna (5:16)

 

2. Album Version/The Immaculate Collection – QSound Mix (4:00)

 

3. Album Version/Celebration (4:00)

(It was established this was a different mix to The Immaculate Collection version)

 

4. Edit (3:58) (It's That Girl Cassette) (Edit of New Mix)

(This one I'm confused about, apparently it's the identical to the Japanese CD Single Collection, but is it also the same as: Remix Edit/Edit (Radio Version) (3:56)

even though it's listed separately on Remixology?)

 

5. Remix Edit/Edit (Radio Version) (3:56)

(See above?)

 

6. Edit (3:59) (CD Single Collection)

(Is this Identical to It's That Girl Cassette but different mastering)??

 

7. Fade (3:59)

8. U.S Remix/New Mix/Extended Remix (6:56)

9. Instrumental Dub (5:43)

10. First Album Sessions – Demo 2-18-83 (4:38)

11. Virgin Tour Rehearsal (14:34)

12. Sticky & Sweet Tour Version (3:53)

13. Sticky & Sweet Tour – iTunes Digital Download (3:46)

14. Demo – Multitrack (24 Tracks) (6:30)

15. Video Version (Rockamerica Remix) (5:30) (Unsure if official)

16. Video Version (3:56) (The Immaculate Collection DVD) (Celebration DVD)

(Is this version the same as: Remix Edit/Edit (Radio Version)

The Borderline (Edit) is the same that appeared on all 7“ releases and the Japanese Single Collection. It sounds a little different because the one from the 7“ vinyls doesn’t come from a digital source unlike the one on the Single Collection. It‘s also a completely different mix and not an edit of the album version.

 

Borderline (Remix Edit) from the It‘s That Girl casette is unique. It’s an edit of the New Mix.

 

I don’t know about the fade version. I suppose it comes from some Philippinian release or something.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.