Jump to content

Best Album Ranking


12inch
 Share

Recommended Posts

5 minutes ago, PWCCA said:

Least favourite to favourite...

Hard Candy

Rebel Heart

MDNA

Celebration

American Life

GHV2

Confessions on a Dancefloor

Music

Something to Remember

Bedtime Stories

Madonna

Like a Virgin

True Blue

You Can Dance

I'm Breathless

Ray of Light

Like a Prayer

The Immaculate Collection

Erotica

Really happy to see You Can Dance high on your chart. Honestly it’s my all-time most listened to record of hers. Soooo good. Something to Remember is incredible as well. And yes, Erotica if my number one as well!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, 12inch said:

Really happy to see You Can Dance high on your chart. Honestly it’s my all-time most listened to record of hers. Soooo good. Something to Remember is incredible as well. And yes, Erotica if my number one as well!

As a child of the 80s, YCD was part of my life soundtrack. I think its a great album

Link to comment
Share on other sites

From best to worst: 

 

1. Ray of Light (best)

2. True Blue

3. Like a Virgin

4. American Life

5. Hard Candy

6. Confessions on a Dance Floor

7. Erotica

8. Madonna

9. Bedtime Stories

10. Rebel Heart

11. Like a Prayer

12. Music

13. MDNA

14. I'm Breathless

15. Who's That Girl

16. Evita

17. Celebration

18. Something to Remember

19. The Immaculate Collection

20. You Can Dance

21. Remixed & Revisited

22. GHV2 (worst)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

mine are

main albums:

  1. ray of light (best)
  2. bedtime stories
  3. confessions on a dancefloor
  4. erotica
  5. like a prayer
  6. Madonna
  7. like a virgin
  8. music
  9. true blue
  10. American life
  11. hard candy
  12. rebel heart
  13. mdna (worst)

soundtrack albums:

  1. who's that girl (best)
  2. I'm breathless
  3. Evita (worst)

compilation albums:

  1. the immaculate collection (best)
  2. ghv2
  3. celebration
  4.  you can dance
  5. something to remember
  6. remixed and revisited (worst)

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My qualitative classification any time. By setting aside the effect of the modes.

 

True Blue (best)

Ray of Light

Confessions on a Dancefloor

Music

Hard Candy

Like a Prayer

Erotica

American Life

I'm Breathless

Like a Virgin

Madonna

MDNA

Bedtime Stories

Rebel Heart (worst)

My personal ranking 2019 taking into account the impact of time and the old-fashioned effect

 

Hard Candy (best)

MDNA

Confessions on a Dancefloor

Music

Erotica

I'm Breathless

True Blue

Rebel Heart

Bedtime Stories

Like a Prayer

American Life

Like a Virgin

Ray of Light

Madonna (worst)

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

12 hours ago, luckystar1983 said:
  1. Like a Prayer (Favorite)
  2. Like a Virgin
  3. I'm Breathless
  4. True Blue
  5. The Immaculate Collection
  6. Bedtime Stories
  7. Madonna
  8. Something to Remember
  9. You Can Dance
  10. Erotica
  11. Ray Of Light
  12. Celebration
  13. Music
  14. GHV2
  15. Remixed & Revisited 
  16. American Life
  17. Rebel Heart
  18. Hard Candy
  19. Confessions on a Dance Floor
  20. MDNA (Least favorite)

 

I’m glad to see confessions so low. I love Future Lovers and Let It Will Be but not into the rest of the album much.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

ALBUMS

1.- Like A Prayer [Perfect]

2.- Erotica [Brilliant]

3.- Ray Of Light [The Best]

4.- Music [Invention]

5.- Madonna [Dance]

6.- True Blue [Love]

7.- Confession On A Dancefloor [Party]

8.- Bedtime Stories [Sing]

9.- American Life [Anthem]

10.- Like A Virgin [Innocence]

11.- Hard Candy [Younger]

12.- Rebel Heart [Too Much]

13.- MDNA [Bold]

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Here’s mine:

1. Erotica (best)

2. You Can Dance

3. American Life

4. Like a Prayer

5. Something to Remember 

6. Immaculate Collection

7. Rebel Heart super deluxe 

8. Madonna

9. Celebration double disk

10. Hard Candy

11. True Blue

12. Like a Virgin

13. I’m Breathless

14. Music 

15. Bedtime Stories

16. MDNA

17. Ray of Light 

18. Confessions on a Dance Floor 

19. GHV2 (worst)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This changes all the time and was extremely difficult. Let me add before posting my ranking that I enjoy each album and find them all to have gems and don't consider any of them to be bad:

True Blue
Ray of Light
Confessions on a Dance Floor
American Life
Bedtime Stories
Like a Prayer
Madonna
Like a Virgin
Hard Candy
Erotica
I'm Breathless
Music
Rebel Heart
MDNA

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Bedtime stories ? ( best vocal and melodies ) 

erotica ( masterpiece) 

True blue ( the perfect pop ) 

Madonna ( iconic ) 

Ray of light ( amzing brilliantly) 

like a Virgin ( classic ) 

music ( love ❤️

american life ( simple yet unique ) 

confessions ( also brilliant one) 

like a prayer ( some amazing some weak ) 

 rebel heart ( same thought ) 

mdna ( same ) 

hard candy ? ( some songs I can’t stand here ) 

 

something to remember ( too good ?) 

celebration ? 

the immeculte collection ?

you can dance ??‍♀️

ghv2 ( useless collection ) ?

revesied remixed ?

 

whos that girl ( 4 perfect songs ) 

I’m breathless ( classic )

and evita ... :*) 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Oh great topic! 

Let me in:

 

MDNA

You Can Dance

GHV2

Erotica

I’m Breathless

American Life

Hard Candy

Celebration

The Immaculate Collection

Rebel Heart

Madonna

Like a Virgin

True Blue

Music

Bedtime Stories

Something to Remember

Like a Prayer

Confessions on a Dance Floor

Ray of Light

 

So, the thing is, I never listen to the compilations in their original forms except for “Something to Remember”. I made my own versions for each one with all the missing gems that I think should have been included. For “Rebel Heart”, I also listen to my own version that lacks some of the “faulty” songs, and considering the abundance of the tracks, my version doesn’t really feel like an abridged one. And “You Can Dance” has never been an album I put on every now and then. That’s why they are put towards the end of my list. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. Something To Remember

2. Ray Of Light

3. The Immaculate Collection

4. Like A Prayer

5. True Blue

6. Music

7. Confessions On A Dance Floor

8. I'm Breathless

9. Rebel Heart

10. Erotica

11. Like A Virgin

12. Bedtime Stories

13. Madonna

14. MDNA

15. Evita

16. American Life

17. Hard Candy

18. Celebration

19. You Can Dance

20. Who's That Girl

21. GHV2

22. Remixed & Revisited

 

Live Albums:

1. Confessions Tour

2. Rebel Heart Tour

3. Sticky & Sweet Tour

4. I'm Gonna Tell You A Secret

5. MDNA World Tour

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Write here...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Terms of Use