MeantToBeIconic

I think if all I'm gonna get is salt and no positive reception, consider the countdown DOA I haven't heard a single good thing, so I'm not interested anymore Sorry y'all! I tried

FWIW I intentionally skipped most of I'm Breathless seeing as how it's a soundtrack, aside from the singles which had at least some impact on her career, and one off non-Madonna compilation tracks for lack of significance, but these are solid suggestions once put in context. Will update with the full list

Hi everybody! Long time no see! I used to be a very active member in the forum, but slipped away for a short time bc of medical issues and life needing very heavy attention, but I'm on top of everything now! Should be creeping around the comments again now :p But I thought, what better way to reintroduce myself than reviving my ranking game I did after Rebel Heart dropped, and I'm back back back back back again with the revamp! We had a whole new album since then, so I think it's time to go again! Participation is very simple, just download the excel sheet, fill it out where the blanks are, then send it to me! The blank doc is only 9kb, so a Dm should be perfect. After the voting window closes, I'll average everything out, then start a countdown announcing worst to best in sequential order, as well as averages of albums for that ranking as well for a final bonus reveal! Excel Here:MadonnaScoreSheet.xlsx I'll have the submission window open until the 31st, finish out the entire month. If the file ends up too big for DMs, let me know for an alt method. Have fun everyone! And comment and like to keep this at the top of the list

Couldn't have said it better myself Except Holy Water isn't a turd it's a masterpiece >:(

I'M SORRY EVERYONE IT'S FINALS SEASON AT MY SCHOOL MY ATTENTION WAS NEEDED ELSEWHERE BUT NOW I WILL REVEAL UP TO THE END OF THE STANDARD EDITION OF THE ALBUM STARTING WITH Hold Tight In the order of Album/Demo/Freedom the votes went Album: 3 Demo: 15 Freedom: 1 And we have our first major shift! The Tedder production is thrown out in favor of MNEK's more house like bounce! Next Joan of Arc In order of Album/Demo/Tragic Girl the votes are Album: 5 Demo: 11 Tragic Girl: 3 And another demo takes a spot! The more energetic demo is replaced by the smoother, more melancholic demo. Iconic (feat. Mike Tyson & Chance the Rapper) In the order of Album/Demo/Alone with You the votes are Album: 11 Demo: 7 Alone With You: 1 And the album version stays, taking it's rightful place over the underproduced demos HeartBreakCity In the order of Album/Demo/Tragic Girl the results are Album: 7 Demo: 12 Tragic Girl: 0 The demos, with extra vocals and productions, manage to outdo the powerful, yet somewhat tepid, album version Body Shop In the order of Album/Demo/Back that Up Album: 15 Demo: 2 Back That Up: 2 The demos warbly synths did not make enough of a difference to knock the mild and erratic album version from it's spot Holy Water In The Order of Album/Demo/Never Let You Go Album: 11 Demo: 1 Never Let You Go: 7 Despite initial fan backlash, we still love this song's pussy best, and can't get rid of it (suck it bitches) Inside Out In the order of Album/Demo/Take It Back Album: 6 Demo: 10 Take It Back: 1 And the more intimate, romantic album version is replaced with a grittier, electronic version found in the demo! Last one Wash All Over Me In the order of Album/Demo/God Is Love Album: 7 Demo: 10 God Is Love: 1 And Avicii has his demo on the tracklist, while the stripped down album version is given the boot And now we're caught up! Thoughts???

The results are tallied, I'm revealing slowly

Diplo's air horns (his signature) and like that's IT

Back with more results Unapologetic Bitch The votes were for Album: 15 Demo: 2 Two Steps Behind Me: 2 You know, I thought the demo could've won here but OBVIOUSLY I am very wrong Illuminati Votes were in the order of Album: 9 Demo: 6 Trust No Bitch: 3 The Kanye production is just barely able to squeak out over the more uproarious demo, leaving Trust No Bitch in the dust Bitch I'm Madonna The votes went Album: 9 Demo: 8 Score: 2 Oh man talk about CLOSE. Score wasn't able to score a goal, but the album just BARELY beat the solo demo. Nicki really helps here I guess

AS far as the "Demo" option is concerned, it was left up to personal opinion, so whichever of the available ones you would have preferred

Took me a while, but I got there Here we will get to see the Madonna Infinity version of Madonna's 13th album, Rebel Heart! We'll do three tracks every two or three days! Thank you all for your votes! Let's jump in with the first three Living For Love Votes in the order of Album/Demo/Never Let You Go the results were Album: 14 Demo: 4 Never Let You Go: 1 The album version wins in a landslide!! Rightfully so. Devil Pray Votes in the order of Album/Demo/Nothing Lasts Forever Album: 9 Demo: 8 Nothing Lasts Forever: 1 Eking out just barely, the dark album version barely trumps the Westernized demo! Ghosttown Votes in the order of Album/Heaven Album: 13 Heaven: 4 I expected a much tighter race, but here we are with an obvious winner. An amazing ballad that deserves a place on an amazing album. There are your results. Check back later for the next 3

Does anyone remember when I did this a year ago???

Y'all, we have a lot more votes and we have ONE WEEK LEFT Question is, do I reveal one track at a time, or do the whole thing all at once?