Rank the Lead Singles

[valinecode 291]

Like a Prayer - Hung Up - Music - Secret - Erotica - Everybody - Like a Virgin - Medellín - GMAYL - 4' - American Life - Live to Tell - Frozen - Living for Love

[BillyBongo 227]

Erotica for me. Memories of watching the video premiere on Channel 4 late night in the UK and scared my Dad would walk in ?

[Italo Gianti 317]

1. Like a Prayer

2. Erotica

3. Frozen

4. Secret

5. Hung Up

6. Everybody

7. Live to Tell

8. American Life

9. Music

10. 4 Minutes

11. Medellín

12. Like a Virgin

13. Give Me All Your Luvin’

14. Living for Love

[angelamanda623 327]

AHHH!, this one was hard. 

Commercially, no doubt, it would go to "Like A Prayer".  When that song came out, it had everyone circulating around the album.  There couldn't have been better publicity.  

BUT...I'm thinking as far as the song itself or the impact it had.

With that being said, my choice would go to "Everybody".  What better impact than to introduce the world to the phenom we now know as Madonna?!  It was the tune that started it all.  

My (close) second choice would be "Frozen".  I still remember when I first saw its video; I was awestruck.  I had already been an M fan for well over 10 years but nothing fixated me the way that it did (at least at that time).  

So, in order from 1st choice to last choice:  

"Everybody"

"Frozen"

"Music"

"Like A Virgin"

"Hung Up"

"Like A Prayer"

"Living For Love"

"Erotica"

"American Life"

"4 Minutes"

”Live to Tell”

”Secret”

”Give Me All Your Luvin’”

 

(Note:  These songs are definitely not in the order of which I like best to which I like least, although I love "Everybody".  Hell, some of these songs at the top of this list aren't even in my Top 100.)

[PWCCA 2,498]

First to last...

1. Like a Prayer

2. Vogue

3. Frozen

4. Like a Virgin

5. Hung Up

6. Erotica

7. Secret

8. Music

9. Live to Tell

10. Everybody

11. Give Me All Your Lovin'

12. American Life

13. Living For Love

14. Medellin

15. 4 Minutes