POLL: Greatest Hits Collection Help: Part 1 (Holiday, Lucky Star, Borderline)

[Idle Queen 87]

Hey what’s good,

Just like the last poll I created asking which versions of a few songs you think would work best on the singles collection, I’m going to do the same thing here and ask you which versions (track by track) you want/would like to see on the upcoming greatest hits collection that I’m currently curating.

Thanks for your opinion and input.
 

Edit: Here's part two of the poll with the next three songs on the tracklist!

[Bitch I’m Madonna 4,678]

Holiday:

You Can Dance Single Edit

- It was done by Jellybean, the original producer of the song himself and it's by far the best edit of the song that doesn't sound too different from the original. It's along the lines of the original 7" Edit but it sounds less choppy. The TIC version is also really good, if not better but it's very different from the original imo.

Lucky Star:

Q-Sound Mix / TIC Version

- This edit is the only one that properly manages to edit the song without any choppy transitions. The original edit has a very bad edit point at 2:00 for example where it goes from the "Cause I know you're gonna make everything alright" to "You may be my lucky star...". This has been fixed in the Q-Sound Mix

Borderline:

I went with the original 7" Edit but the Radio Version (from She's Breathless) is also quite good. The former one is the version used in the music video.

[jemboy1973 663]

I love the video Edit of Lucky Star with the extra echo on the "He Yeahs" later in the song. Same with the Borderline mix with the Borderline echo near the end of the song.