Poll: MDNA Tour or Rebel Heart Tour?

[geert 3,041]

Poll: MDNA Tour or Rebel Heart Tour?

[geert 3,041]

MDNA Tour

[PWCCA 2,498]

Neither could be regarded as amongst her best, but I would have to go with the MDNA Tour. It had a great intro, and some high points amongst the setlist... I also loved that Vogue corset. Sadly, it had a pretty shitty finale. Rebel Heart tour was just rather dull, and unimaginative.

[Enrico 15,788]

Despite a bad opening and a dull ending, RHT was more relaxed, I loved the unexpected songs.

MDNA was a tour the force that often prevented M from singing live, she relied too heavily on backing tracks.

[Fighter 28,797]

MDNA Tour was super exciting. But im glad we're transitioning towards a different type of show now. 

[Voguerista 11,738]

Both so good, but I'll go with Rebel Heart. I couldn't get enough of her dancing. 

[Kieran 1,155]

I’m surprised to see MDNA doing so well over RH. I loved MDNA thematically, but some of the song choices means that for me it does not stand the test of time too well.

RH I loved her warmth and when I left the arena I was on such a high... first time that I had such feelings since seeing her for the first time at DWT.

A mix of MDNAs narrative with RHTs warmth and songs, would be ? 

[tifenn 99]

On 8/16/2019 at 11:24 PM, PWCCA said:

Neither could be regarded as amongst her best, but I would have to go with the MDNA Tour. It had a great intro, and some high points amongst the setlist... I also loved that Vogue corset. Sadly, it had a pretty shitty finale. Rebel Heart tour was just rather dull, and unimaginative.

I agree with you. The RHT was rushed and I hate her voice in most of the songs  (I have the same feeling for Madame X by the way - sorry I'm off the topic... ).

 

[BillyBongo 227]

I saw MDNA live and it was a miserable experience. Came on stage so late that she had to cut out some songs, one of which was Like a Virgin (!) She just couldn't seem to get the crowd on her side after such a late start, there was a bad atmosphere by the time she came on. A real shame. So Even though I never saw it live, I'd choose Rebel Heart Tour.

[bedtimestory 758]

Rebel Heart Tour had a great and variable setlist!

On the date I saw her, she was 3 hours late! Show started after 12am, When it was supposed to be at ''8pm'' At 8:30 she was still rehearsing burning up, and she never acknowledged being late or apologized to the crowd!

It was like a greatest hits tour, Come on! we even got Take a Bow! She gave us many many bonuses.

[rlittler81 1,601]

13 hours ago, BillyBongo said:

I saw MDNA live and it was a miserable experience. Came on stage so late that she had to cut out some songs, one of which was Like a Virgin (!) She just couldn't seem to get the crowd on her side after such a late start, there was a bad atmosphere by the time she came on. A real shame. So Even though I never saw it live, I'd choose Rebel Heart Tour.

Funny, that was my exact experience at seeing the Rebel Heart tour in Manchester. Hours late, no atmosphere, songs cut. Was beyond disappointed. MDNA I saw twice (Birmingham and Edinburgh) and loved it each time. Theatrical, daring... the 90s tour that never was!

[*mlvc* 823]

MDNA relied too heavily on the MDNA album. While I think there was more energy to the MDNA tour I feel that RH had a much better set list and was more enjoyable if you actually wanted to hear Madonna sing.

[Guest Nobody Knows Me]

The MDNA Tour for me. I didn’t see it live and yet I still find it thrilling and I definitely think it is one of her best and most innovative and tours to date. The stage, costumes, choreography, all amazing. Girl Gone Wild, Gang Bang, Give Me All Your Luvin, Vogue, I’m Addicted and Celebration / Give It 2 Me are personal highlights.

Rebel Heart Tour is also great but I only managed to get into that tour recently. I also didn’t see it live and therefore had to rely on that horribly edited DVD until I could find a decent bootleg, and it wasn’t until I saw the bootleg that I really appreciated it. 

[Vinny Fonseca 98]

Rebel Heart Tour

[nito84bcn 2,734]

Rebel Heart Tour! 

[Alan Leggate 165]

Rebel Heart for sure. It was just a great, upbeat and fun show. Also, I detest stadium concerts, so I was much more happy in an arena. I still skip most of the first section, but from then on it's great and (well first leg anyway) she was happy on stage and we got a fab mix of old neglected 80's tunes.