MEGARATE: Erotica era [Results Show - Recap on first page]

[Tony Fortin 1,780]

That's it I voted ..... a lot of hesitation to choose which one to give my 11

[Curtains 13,280]

42 votes in three days. You rock! Guess this will be one of the megarates with the most votes.

[Polaris 139]

Voted

[deathproof 10,555]

01 - Erotica 10/10

02 - Fever 8/10

03 - Bye Bye Baby 8/10

04 - Deeper and Deeper 10/10 

05 - Where Life Begins 8/10 

06 - Bad Girl 10/10

07 - Waiting 11/10

08 - Thief of Hearts 9/10 

09 - Words 9/10 

10 - Rain 10/10 

11 - Why's It So Hard 7/10 

12 - In This Life 7/10

13 - Secret Garden 10/10 

14 - Goodbye to Innocence 10/10 

15 - This Used to Be My Playground 10/10

[deathproof 10,555]

Hey curtie, you forgot Did You Do It and Up And Down Suite. Even Waiting Remix too

[Bohh 14]

Voted (but I added DYDI which is an official track and shouldn't be left apart - I love the track)

[patrice1711 2,083]

VOTED!!!!!!!! WHIPPPPPP

[PanditaRulez 16,060]

20 hours ago, deathproof said:

01 - Erotica 10/10

02 - Fever 8/10

03 - Bye Bye Baby 8/10

04 - Deeper and Deeper 10/10 

05 - Where Life Begins 8/10 

06 - Bad Girl 10/10

07 - Waiting 11/10

08 - Thief of Hearts 9/10 

09 - Words 9/10 

10 - Rain 10/10 

11 - Why's It So Hard 7/10 

12 - In This Life 7/10

13 - Secret Garden 10/10 

14 - Goodbye to Innocence 10/10 

15 - This Used to Be My Playground 10/10

You had to send this by DM not posted it here. ?

[MattyMads 5,489]

Voted

[deathproof 10,555]

1 hour ago, PanditaRulez said:

You had to send this by DM not posted it here. ?

I don’t care. I make my own rules

[MadonnasPussy 299]

On 2/27/2022 at 7:26 PM, deathproof said:

Hey curtie, you forgot Did You Do It and Up And Down Suite. Even Waiting Remix too

Maybe Up Down Suite and The Waiting Remix but Did You Do It is shit and deserves to be excluded

[deathproof 10,555]

19 minutes ago, MadonnasPussy said:

Maybe Up Down Suite and The Waiting Remix but Did You Do It is shit and deserves to be excluded

It’s such a fun song

[EgoRod 5,430]

5 hours ago, deathproof said:

It’s such a fun song

I think the reason behind it is that Updown and DYDI are remixes / reversions of another song in the album.

But we did include Beast Within with Immaculate collection...

I personally will include both...I like them both

[Curtains 13,280]

9 hours ago, EgoRod said:

I think the reason behind it is that Updown and DYDI are remixes / reversions of another song in the album.

But we did include Beast Within with Immaculate collection...

I personally will include both...I like them both

But then we should have included Erotic right?

At least The Beast Within was treated as its own song when performed live.

[deathproof 10,555]

Yes for Erotic.

[MadonnasPussy 299]

Queen's English (Mo Mo's In The House) - 6/10

Up Down Suite - 7/10

Waiting Remix - 7/10

Did You Do It? - 0/10 DIE!

[EgoRod 5,430]

13 hours ago, Curtains said:

But then we should have included Erotic right?

At least The Beast Within was treated as its own song when performed live.

I think Erotic and Waiting are falling more into the remix side.

But DYDI and Up & Down are more like two different songs, as the Best Within could be considered a different song. In the same way we don't put together Goodbye to Innocence and Fever

[Enrico 15,788]

Excuse me, why everybody talks about Up Down Suite as a song while it's just a (boring) dub of Goodbye to innocence?

[migsou 1,060]

42 minutes ago, Enrico said:

Excuse me, why everybody talks about Up Down Suite as a song while it's just a (boring) dub of Goodbye to innocence?

boring?

[Enrico 15,788]

10 minutes ago, migsou said:

boring?

I'm sorry... I love Goodbye to innocence. I need lyrics.

Up up up down down down:

 

[migsou 1,060]

44 minutes ago, Enrico said:

I'm sorry... I love Goodbye to innocence. I need lyrics.

Up up up down down down:

 

[Curtains 13,280]

Just reached 50 votes everyone!

[Nowheretohide 249]

Voted.

[maddy1111 1,577]

On 3/2/2022 at 9:04 PM, Curtains said:

Just reached 50 votes everyone!

Any chance to do ratings of the rest of her albums in one-go since the forum is clearly shutting down at the end of this month? I know it will be a lot of work for you, but this megarates were so much fun for me, cannot believe it is gonna be over. Or are you planning to continue with this on some other Madonna forum? 

[Curtains 13,280]

10 hours ago, HC Charge said:

Any chance to do ratings of the rest of her albums in one-go since the forum is clearly shutting down at the end of this month? I know it will be a lot of work for you, but this megarates were so much fun for me, cannot believe it is gonna be over. Or are you planning to continue with this on some other Madonna forum? 

I will consider it after the Erotica rate though the format of the results show might be affected by this.

I also considered taking the reigns of the forum cause i don't want to let it go, however i never did such a thing before so someone would have to explain it to me.