Jump to content

Which remix is better than the original?


Recommended Posts

"Celebration" remix is much better than the original version - but it took me years to see that.

The rest... no. She's had incredible remixes through the years, some of them at the same level than the album versions, but not better. For instance, I don't think the "Express Yourself" remix is better than the album version, just different.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

Ooh, this is a good one.

Immediately "Nothing Really Matters" and all of its remixes come to mind. Depends on my mood, but the original is still great.

The Orbital mix of "Bedtime Story" has a slight edge over the original which is still amazing.

Strobe's '92 Mix of "Living For Love"

Offer Nissim's mix of "God Control".

Chris Cox's remix of "IDSIF"

Paul Andrew's Mix/ Red Top'x Mix of "Ghosttown"

Above & Beyond "WIFLFAG"

Thee Retro Lectro DUB of "Die Another Day"

Oakenfold Mixes of "Hollywood", "Sorry" and "American Life".

Peter's Classic Mix of "Nothing Fails".

Thin White Duke Mixes of "I Love NY" and "Miles Away"

Link to comment
Share on other sites

35 minutes ago, judas2015 said:

For me Fever video remix is better than the album version.

They gonna kill me... but my list: Burning Up, Dress You Up, Open Your Heart, Where's the Party, Like A Prayer (7'' Version), Express Yourself, Cherish, Keep It Together, Fever, Bye Bye Baby, Secret, Bedtime Story, Frozen, Ray of Light, Nothing Really Matters, Beautiful Stranger, WIFLFAG, 4 minutes, Give It 2 Me, Celebration...

I'm a fan thanks to her classic singles and remixes, not thanks to her classic albums. But after Confessions/2005 I prefer the album versions, except for a couple of songs.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, Pootz333 said:

 

Ooh, this is a good one.

Immediately "Nothing Really Matters" and all of its remixes come to mind. Depends on my mood, but the original is still great.

The Orbital mix of "Bedtime Story" has a slight edge over the original which is still amazing.

Strobe's '92 Mix of "Living For Love"

Offer Nissim's mix of "God Control".

Chris Cox's remix of "IDSIF"

Paul Andrew's Mix/ Red Top'x Mix of "Ghosttown"

Above & Beyond "WIFLFAG"

Thee Retro Lectro DUB of "Die Another Day"

Oakenfold Mixes of "Hollywood", "Sorry" and "American Life".

Peter's Classic Mix of "Nothing Fails".

Thin White Duke Mixes of "I Love NY" and "Miles Away"

Offer Nissim's mix of "God Control".

i love that one so much!!!! great choice 🐒

Link to comment
Share on other sites

16 minutes ago, truerebel said:

What it feels like for a girl (Above and beyond)

Celebration ( Benny Benassi)

I don't search I find (Honey Dijon)

If the Above and Beyond mix from the video had full lyrics I would say that. I dont' know why they didn't do that as I remember a fan made a version with all lyrics intact and it totally worked. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Good topic and hard as her originals are so brilliant and the remixes are sometimes as good or even better

Bedtime Story - Lush Vocal Mix Mark Picchiotti

Human Nature - Runway Club Mix Danny Tenaglia 

Ray of Light - Both Sasha mixes (but love the original too)

Hollywood - Paul Oakenfold, Thin White Duke Mix and Sander K mix

Nobody Knows Me - Re-Invention Tour v

Die Another Day - Brother Brown Remix

I Love New York  - Thin White Duke Mix

Erotica - Confession Tour

4 Minutes - Matt Green Bootleg Dub/Pryda

Give It To Me - Fedde Le Grand Remix

Miles Away - Peter Raugher Final Mix Part 3

Falling Free - Deep Stereo Seen Molly ReMix

Love Spent - TAJ Stringseational remix

Gang Bang - Robin Skouteris mixed with Nancy Sinatra Bang Bang

Living For Love - Paul Andrews Remix

Bitch I'm Madonna - Robin Skouteris mixed with Michael Jackson Beat It

Crave - Tracy Young Remix

I Rise - Tracy Young Remix

I Don't Search I Find - Honey Dijon Remix

Link to comment
Share on other sites

16 minutes ago, MDNA22 said:

Good topic and hard as her originals are so brilliant and the remixes are sometimes as good or even better

Bedtime Story - Lush Vocal Mix Mark Picchiotti

Human Nature - Runway Club Mix Danny Tenaglia 

Ray of Light - Both Sasha mixes (but love the original too)

Hollywood - Paul Oakenfold, Thin White Duke Mix and Sander K mix

Nobody Knows Me - Re-Invention Tour v

Die Another Day - Brother Brown Remix

I Love New York  - Thin White Duke Mix

Erotica - Confession Tour

4 Minutes - Matt Green Bootleg Dub/Pryda

Give It To Me - Fedde Le Grand Remix

Miles Away - Peter Raugher Final Mix Part 3

Falling Free - Deep Stereo Seen Molly ReMix

Love Spent - TAJ Stringseational remix

Gang Bang - Robin Skouteris mixed with Nancy Sinatra Bang Bang

Living For Love - Paul Andrews Remix

Bitch I'm Madonna - Robin Skouteris mixed with Michael Jackson Beat It

Crave - Tracy Young Remix

I Rise - Tracy Young Remix

I Don't Search I Find - Honey Dijon Remix

The Lush Vocal Mix of Bedtime Story is so underrated. I like it more than Junior's mix.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Erotica (WO REMIX) also LOVE ERotica In my Jeep remix 

human nature (howie tee) this is the one I always play 

bye bye baby (NY hip hop remix )

American Life (Missy Elliot American Dream Remix ) 

love don’t live here anymore (soul power remix) 

don’t cry for me Argentina (Miami mix) 

waiting (remix ft Everlast) 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

People really saying that Honey Dijon IDSIF over the masterpiece that is the original. What kind of world are we living in :dead:

 

I don’t like many of her remixes over the original but I think Fever Edit Two is. Oh and I guess if the tour version of Future counts but that’s like a different version completely lol

Link to comment
Share on other sites

28 minutes ago, Shoful said:

People really saying that Honey Dijon IDSIF over the masterpiece that is the original. What kind of world are we living in :dead:

 

I don’t like many of her remixes over the original but I think Fever Edit Two is. Oh and I guess if the tour version of Future counts but that’s like a different version completely lol

That Honey Dijon remix just feels like a fan re-edit of the album version to me. The remixes of IDSIF by Chris Cox, Kue, Monsieur Adi, Joel Dickerson and Matt Moss are so good. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This changes from time to time and some choices might be controversial but here's my list (exclusing the tour versions and demos). It doesn't mean that the originals are bad by any means, but I sometimes end up being tired of the originals after playing them over and over.

 

-Borderline (Single Mix)

-Causing a Commotion (Silver Screen Single Mix)

-Express Yourself (Any of the Pettibone remixes, the Q-Sound Mix being my favorite)

-Keep It Together (Single Mix)

-Hanky Panky (Bare Bones Single Mix)

-Justify My Love (Orbit Edit)

-Fever (Edit One)

-Bye Bye Baby (House Mix)

-Bedtime Story (Junior's Single Mix)

-Human Nature (Howie Tee Remix)

-Love Don't Live Here Anymore (David Reitzas Remix)

-You Must Love Me (Single Version)

-Don't Cry for Me Argentina (Miami Mix Edit)

-Ray of Light (Sasha Ultra Violet Mix Edit)

-Nothing Really Matters (Club 69 Radio Mix)

-Don't Tell Me (Thunderpuss' 2001 Hands in the Air Radio)

-What It Feels Like for a Girl (Above & Beyond Club Video Mix)

-Hollywood (Jacques Lu Cont's Thin White Duck Edit)

-Love Profusion (Headcleanr Rock Mix)

-Let It Will Be (Paper Faces Vocal Edit)

-Give Me All Your Luvin' (Demolition Crew Remix)

-Girl Gone Wild (Justin Cognito Radio Edit)

-Bitch I'm Madonna (Diplo Mix)

-I Don't Search I Find (Kue's Studio 54 Edit)

 

AND many of the Q-Sound Mixes if you want to count those (though most of you will consider them alternate versions): Holiday, Like a Virgin, Material Girl, Crazy for You, Into the Groove, Live to Tell and Vogue.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Write here...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share


×
×
  • Create New...