Why Causing a Commotion isn't on FEL ?

[Leona Helmsley 9,418]

9 minutes ago, MPowered said:

These are her actual Dance chart #1s:

1. Holiday / Lucky Star
2. Like A Virgin
3. Material Girl
4. Angel / Into The Groove
5. Open Your Heart
6. Causing A Commotion
7. You Can Dance (LP Cuts) (Spotlight, Holiday, Everybody, Physical Attraction, Over And Over, Into The Groove, Where's The Party)
8. Like A Prayer
9. Express Yourself
10. Keep It Together
11. Vogue
12. Justify My Love
13. Erotica
14. Deeper And Deeper
15. Fever
16. Secret
17. Bedtime Story
18. Don't Cry For Me Argentina
19. Frozen
20. Ray Of Light
21. Nothing Really Matters
22. Beautiful Stranger
23. American Pie
24. Music
25. Don't Tell Me
26. What It Feels Like For A Girl
27. Impressive Instant
28. Die Another Day
29. American Life
30. Hollywood
31. Me Against The Music
32. Nothing Fails
33. Love Profusion
34. Hung Up
35. Sorry
36. Get Together
37. Jump
38. 4 Minutes
39. Give It 2 Me
40. Celebration
41. Give Me All Your Luvin'
42. Girl Gone Wild
43. Turn Up The Radio
44. Living For Love
45. Ghosttown
46. Bitch, I'm Madonna
47. Medellín
48. I Rise
49. Crave
50. I Don't Search I Find

This would have been perfect. I don't understand why they added both, Physical Attraction AND Everybody. Everybody is somewhat understandable as it was her very first entry and hit #3. Lucky Star should have been added instead of Me Against The Music.

What iconic songs!!!!!!

(Welcome back dear @MPowered..... It was few days i dont see you here.... Hope everthing ok.....)

[Pud 147]

On 8/15/2023 at 3:28 PM, Scottyx said:

It wasn't even played on the radio

it was played often in los angeles 

[Pud 147]

On 10/8/2022 at 12:10 PM, אביחי אפשטיין said:

How did it happen that this amazing hit didn't make it into the complation? After all, the song reached #1 first at the chart.
I would really like to hear an unreleased version or at least a remastered version of one of the classic remixes.
On the same FEL topic, I was the only one who bothered that there was a break in the chronology with the remixes from "You can dance"?

a tragedy that its not included.  one of her greatest remixes of all time. 

i've noticed a lot of times she favors putting something new and current for relevancy and leaves out the good stuff. This was the case on Celebration (greatest hits album), she chose to put Miles Away instead of Give It 2 Me?! Give It 2 Me is one of her greatest songs form the 00's!!! 

also, she knows now that CAC should have been on the set list of Celebration tour. 

One of her all time greatest - also left off The Immaculate.  

[Leona Helmsley 9,418]

21 minutes ago, Pud said:

a tragedy that its not included.  one of her greatest remixes of all time. 

i've noticed a lot of times she favors putting something new and current for relevancy and leaves out the good stuff. This was the case on Celebration (greatest hits album), she chose to put Miles Away instead of Give It 2 Me?! Give It 2 Me is one of her greatest songs form the 00's!!! 

also, she knows now that CAC should have been on the set list of Celebration tour. 

One of her all time greatest - also left off The Immaculate.  

Bravo!

For me too 2 of her biggest GH are  Celebration and Immaculate

[Brendanlovesu1 11,942]

On 1/19/2024 at 10:58 PM, Pud said:

a tragedy that its not included.  one of her greatest remixes of all time. 

i've noticed a lot of times she favors putting something new and current for relevancy and leaves out the good stuff. This was the case on Celebration (greatest hits album), she chose to put Miles Away instead of Give It 2 Me?! Give It 2 Me is one of her greatest songs form the 00's!!! 

also, she knows now that CAC should have been on the set list of Celebration tour. 

One of her all time greatest - also left off The Immaculate.  

I choose to belive that's why The Holiday Collection EP was released with True Blue, Who's That Girl and Causing a Commotion included because there wasn't enough disc space for them to be originally included on The Immaculate Collection

[Cyber-Raga 242]

13 hours ago, Brendanlovesu1 said:

I choose to belive that's why The Holiday Collection EP was released with True Blue, Who's That Girl and Causing a Commotion included because there wasn't enough disc space for them to be originally included on The Immaculate Collection

At one point CAC was considered to be included on TIC instead of Cherish. She went with the more current song back then I guess. 

[BoyToyMark 343]

I would've included Causing A Commotion instead of Physical Attraction. I also would've included Nobody Knows Me instead of the Britney duet.

I would've also added as two bonus tracks Human Nature and Miles Away because they reached number two.

[A. A. Aardvark 4,837]