Jump to content

Track-By-Track: Hard Candy vs MDNA


Future Lover
 Share

Recommended Posts

Here we go again! @@Stevo should be happy! He enjoyed the last one haha. 

 

The rules are simple. Stack the albums track listing side by side and bold which song you prefer out of the two of them. Like so: 

 

 

Candy Shop vs Girl Gone Wild

4 Minutes vs Gang Bang

Give It 2 Me vs I'm Addicted 

Heartbeat vs Turn Up the Radio

Miles Away vs Give Me All Your Luvin' 

She's Not Me vs Some Girls

Incredible vs Superstar

Beat Goes On vs I Don't Give A

Dance 2night vs I'm A Sinner

Spanish Lesson vs Love Spent 

Devil Wouldn't Recognize You vs Masterpiece 

Voices vs Falling Free

 

Hard Candy 8/12

MDNA 4/12

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks @@OhMadonna 😉😉

 

 

 

 

Candy Shop vs Girl Gone Wild

4 Minutes vs Gang Bang

Give It 2 Me vs I'm Addicted

Heartbeat vs Turn Up the Radio

Miles Away vs Give Me All Your Luvin'

She's Not Me vs Some Girls

Incredible vs Superstar(both crappy though)

Beat Goes On vs I Don't Give A

Dance 2night vs I'm A Sinner

Spanish Lesson vs Love Spent

Devil Wouldn't Recognize You vs Masterpiece

Voices vs Falling Free

 

HC 4/12 vs MDNA 8/12

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Alright, I'm game...

 

Candy Shop vs Girl Gone Wild

4 Minutes vs Gang Bang

Give It 2 Me vs I'm Addicted 

Heartbeat vs Turn Up the Radio

Miles Away vs Give Me All Your Luvin' 

She's Not Me vs Some Girls

Incredible vs Superstar

Beat Goes On vs I Don't Give A

Dance 2night vs I'm A Sinner

Spanish Lesson vs Love Spent

Devil Wouldn't Recognize You vs Masterpiece 

Voices vs Falling Free

(super tough for me, since I love both of these songs

pretty much equally - both are very fine album closers)

 

HC 10/12 - MDNA 2/12

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Candy Shop vs Girl Gone Wild


4 Minutes vs Gang Bang


Give It 2 Me vs I'm Addicted 


Heartbeat vs Turn Up the Radio


Miles Away vs Give Me All Your Luvin'


She's Not Me vs Some Girls


Incredible vs Superstar


Beat Goes On vs I Don't Give A


Dance 2night vs I'm A Sinner


Spanish Lesson vs Love Spent 


Devil Wouldn't Recognize You vs Masterpiece 


Voices vs Falling Free


 


Hard Candy 2/12


MDNA 10/12


Link to comment
Share on other sites

Candy Shop vs Girl Gone Wild


4 Minutes vs Gang Bang


Give It 2 Me vs I'm Addicted 


Heartbeat vs Turn Up the Radio


Miles Away vs Give Me All Your Luvin' 


She's Not Me vs Some Girls


Incredible vs Superstar


Beat Goes On vs I Don't Give A


Dance 2night vs I'm A Sinner


Spanish Lesson vs Love Spent


Devil Wouldn't Recognize You vs Masterpiece 


Voices vs Falling Free


 


Hard Candy: 8/12


MDNA: 4/12


 


:Madonna005:


 


 


Link to comment
Share on other sites

Candy Shop vs Girl Gone Wild


4 Minutes vs Gang Bang


Give It 2 Me vs I'm Addicted 


Heartbeat vs Turn Up the Radio


Miles Away vs Give Me All Your Luvin' 


She's Not Me vs Some Girls


Incredible vs Superstar


Beat Goes On vs I Don't Give A


Dance 2night vs I'm A Sinner


Spanish Lesson vs Love Spent 


Devil Wouldn't Recognize You vs Masterpiece 


Voices vs Falling Free


 


Hard Candy 8/12


MDNA 4/12


Link to comment
Share on other sites

Candy Shop vs Girl Gone Wild


4 Minutes vs Gang Bang


Give It 2 Me vs I'm Addicted 


Heartbeat vs Turn Up the Radio


Miles Away vs Give Me All Your Luvin' 


She's Not Me vs Some Girls


Incredible vs Superstar


Beat Goes On vs I Don't Give A


Dance 2night vs I'm A Sinner


Spanish Lesson vs Love Spent 


Devil Wouldn't Recognize You vs Masterpiece 


Voices vs Falling Free


 


Hard Candy 6/12


MDNA 6/12


Link to comment
Share on other sites

Candy Shop vs Girl Gone Wild


4 Minutes vs Gang Bang


Give It 2 Me vs I'm Addicted 


Heartbeat vs Turn Up the Radio


Miles Away vs Give Me All Your Luvin' 


She's Not Me vs Some Girls


Incredible vs Superstar


Beat Goes On vs I Don't Give A


Dance 2night vs I'm A Sinner


Spanish Lesson vs Love Spent 


Devil Wouldn't Recognize You vs Masterpiece 


Voices vs Falling Free


 


HC 5


MDNA 5


Tie 3


 


Bonus


 


Ring My Bell vs 4 bonus songs


Link to comment
Share on other sites

Candy Shop vs Girl Gone Wild


4 Minutes vs Gang Bang


Give It 2 Me vs I'm Addicted 


Heartbeat vs Turn Up the Radio


Miles Away vs Give Me All Your Luvin' 


She's Not Me vs Some Girls


Incredible vs Superstar


Beat Goes On vs I Don't Give A


Dance 2night vs I'm A Sinner


Spanish Lesson vs Love Spent 


Devil Wouldn't Recognize You vs Masterpiece 


Voices vs Falling Free


 


Hard Candy 6/12


MDNA 6/12


Link to comment
Share on other sites

Candy Shop vs Girl Gone Wild


4 Minutes vs Gang Bang


Give It 2 Me vs I'm Addicted 


Heartbeat vs Turn Up the Radio


Miles Away vs Give Me All Your Luvin' 


She's Not Me vs Some Girls


Incredible vs Superstar


Beat Goes On vs I Don't Give A


Dance 2night vs I'm A Sinner


Spanish Lesson vs Love Spent 


Devil Wouldn't Recognize You vs Masterpiece 


Voices vs Falling Free

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Candy Shop vs Girl Gone Wild

4 Minutes vs Gang Bang

Give It 2 Me vs I'm Addicted

Heartbeat vs Turn Up The Radio

Miles Away vs Give Me All Your Luvin'

She's Not Me vs Some Girls

Incredible vs Superstar

Beat Goes On vs I Don't Give A

Dance 2nite vs I'm A Sinner

Spanish Lesson vs Love Spent

Devil Wouldn't Recognize You vs Masterpiece

Voices vs Falling Free

 

I really REALLY love Hard Candy

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I really REALLY love Hard Candy

 

I miss it!! i've been with Tidal for 5 months and so frustrating with taking stuff off and on, not taking requests I mean i've requested Hard Candy maybe 15 times. But then one day they add something that gets me so excited and can't be mad anymore (sorry guys I told my friend the day they had HC is the day I will stop bitching at Bey and Jay). Once you go flac you never go back.  :kiss:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

OhMadonna, just noticed that you're from Knoxville, I live not too far away and have been to Knoxville several times.  Anyways:

 

Candy Shop vs Girl Gone Wild

4 Minutes vs Gang Bang

Give It 2 Me vs I'm Addicted 

Heartbeat vs Turn Up the Radio

Miles Away vs Give Me All Your Luvin' 

She's Not Me vs Some Girls

Incredible vs Superstar

Beat Goes On vs I Don't Give A

(two favorites of mine:  Beat Goes On vs I Don't Give A was tough)

Dance 2night vs I'm A Sinner

Spanish Lesson vs Love Spent 

Devil Wouldn't Recognize You vs Masterpiece 

Voices vs Falling Free

 

Hard Candy 5/12

MDNA 7/12

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Candy Shop vs Girl Gone Wild

 

4 Minutes vs Gang Bang

 

Give It 2 Me vs I'm Addicted

 

Heartbeat vs Turn Up the Radio

 

Miles Away vs Give Me All Your Luvin'

 

She's Not Me vs Some Girls

 

Incredible vs Superstar

 

Beat Goes On vs I Don't Give A

 

Dance 2night vs I'm A Sinner

 

Spanish Lesson vs Love Spent

 

Devil Wouldn't Recognize You vs Masterpiece

 

Voices vs Falling Free

 

 

 

Result : 6 VS 6

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Candy Shop vs Girl Gone Wild


4 Minutes vs Gang Bang


Give It 2 Me vs I'm Addicted 


Heartbeat vs Turn Up the Radio


Miles Away vs Give Me All Your Luvin' 


She's Not Me vs Some Girls


Incredible vs Superstar


Beat Goes On vs I Don't Give A


Dance 2night vs I'm A Sinner


Spanish Lesson vs Love Spent 


Devil Wouldn't Recognize You vs Masterpiece 


Voices vs Falling Free


 


Hard Candy 9/12


MDNA 3/12


Link to comment
Share on other sites

Candy Shop vs Girl Gone Wild


4 Minutes vs Gang Bang


Give It 2 Me vs I'm Addicted 


Heartbeat vs Turn Up the Radio


Miles Away vs Give Me All Your Luvin'


She's Not Me vs Some Girls


Incredible vs Superstar


Beat Goes On vs I Don't Give A


Dance 2night vs I'm A Sinner


Spanish Lesson vs Love Spent


Devil Wouldn't Recognize You vs Masterpiece 


Voices vs Falling Free


 


Hard Candy 7/12


MDNA 5/12


Link to comment
Share on other sites

Candy Shop vs Girl Gone Wild
4 Minutes vs Gang Bang
Give It 2 Me vs I'm Addicted
Heartbeat vs Turn Up the Radio
Miles Away vs Give Me All Your Luvin'
She's Not Me vs Some Girls
Incredible vs Superstar
Beat Goes On vs I Don't Give A
Dance 2night vs I'm A Sinner
Spanish Lesson vs Love Spent
Devil Wouldn't Recognize You vs Masterpiece
Voices vs Falling Free

Hard Candy 7/12
MDNA 5/12

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Candy Shop vs Girl Gone Wild

4 Minutes vs Gang Bang

Give It 2 Me vs I'm Addicted 

Heartbeat vs Turn Up the Radio

Miles Away vs Give Me All Your Luvin' 

She's Not Me vs Some Girls

Incredible vs Superstar

Beat Goes On vs I Don't Give A

Dance 2night vs I'm A Sinner

Spanish Lesson vs Love Spent 

Devil Wouldn't Recognize You vs Masterpiece 

Voices vs Falling Free

 

Hard Candy 8/12

MDNA 4/12
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm on Tapatalk, no option to bold. I will have parenthesis around my winners.

 

Candy Shop vs (Girl Gone Wild)

4 Minutes vs (Gang Bang)

Give It 2 Me vs (I'm Addicted)

(Heartbeat) vs Turn Up the Radio

(Miles Away) vs Give Me All Your Luvin'

(She's Not Me) vs Some Girls

(Incredible) vs Superstar

Beat Goes On vs (I Don't Give A)

(Dance 2night) vs I'm A Sinner

Spanish Lesson vs (Love Spent)

Devil Wouldn't Recognize You vs (Masterpiece)

(Voices) vs Falling Free

 

MDNA: 6

Hard Candy: 6

 

A tie. Because some tracks on both are laughable in comparison

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Candy Shop vs Girl Gone Wild

4 Minutes vs Gang Bang

Give It 2 Me vs I'm Addicted

Heartbeat vs Turn Up the Radio

Miles Away vs Give Me All Your Luvin' 

She's Not Me vs Some Girls

Incredible vs Superstar

Beat Goes On vs I Don't Give A

Dance 2night vs I'm A Sinner

Spanish Lesson vs Love Spent

Devil Wouldn't Recognize You vs Masterpiece 

Voices vs Falling Free

 

HC: 8 MDNA: 4

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Candy Shop vs Girl Gone Wild


4 Minutes vs Gang Bang


Give It 2 Me vs I'm Addicted 


Heartbeat vs Turn Up the Radio


Miles Away vs Give Me All Your Luvin' 


She's Not Me vs Some Girls


Incredible vs Superstar


Beat Goes On vs I Don't Give A


Dance 2night vs I'm a Sinner


Spanish Lesson vs Love Spent 


Devil Wouldn't Recognize You vs Masterpiece 


Voices vs Falling Free


Link to comment
Share on other sites

Candy Shop vs Girl Gone Wild


4 Minutes vs Gang Bang


Give It 2 Me vs I'm Addicted 


Heartbeat vs Turn Up the Radio


Miles Away vs Give Me All Your Luvin' 


She's Not Me vs Some Girls


Incredible vs Superstar


Beat Goes On vs I Don't Give A


Dance 2night vs I'm a Sinner


Spanish Lesson vs Love Spent 


Devil Wouldn't Recognize You vs Masterpiece 


Voices vs Falling Free


Link to comment
Share on other sites

Candy Shop vs Girl Gone Wild


4 Minutes vs Gang Bang


Give It 2 Me vs I'm Addicted 


Heartbeat vs Turn Up the Radio


Miles Away vs Give Me All Your Luvin'


She's Not Me vs Some Girls


Incredible vs Superstar


Beat Goes On vs I Don't Give A


Dance 2night vs I'm A Sinner


Spanish Lesson vs Love Spent


Devil Wouldn't Recognize You vs Masterpiece 


Voices vs Falling Free


Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 4 months later...

Candy Shop vs Girl Gone Wild


4 Minutes vs Gang Bang


Give It 2 Me vs I'm Addicted


Heartbeat vs Turn Up The Radio


Miles Away vs Give Me All Your Luvin'


She's Not Me vs Some Girls


Incredible vs Superstar


Beat Goes On vs I Don't Give A


Dance 2nite vs I'm A Sinner


Spanish Lesson vs Love Spent


Devil Wouldn't Recognize You vs Masterpiece


Voices vs Falling Free


 


Hard Candy: 11


MDNA: 1


 


I find 'Love Spent' a good song with a bad production, but 'Spanish Lesson' is so bad that alnost any song can defeat it.


 


Yes, I wish "MDNA" were just a joke.


Link to comment
Share on other sites

Candy Shop vs Girl Gone Wild (tie)

4 MINUTES vs Gang Bang

Give It 2 Me vs I'M ADDICTED

HEARTBEAT vs Turn Up The Radio

Miles Away vs Give Me All Your Luvin' (tie)

She's Not Me vs SOMEGIRLS

Incredible vs SUPERSTAR

Beat Goes On vs I DON'T GIVE A

Dance 2nite vs I'M A SINNER

Spanish Lesson vs Love Spent (tie)

Devil Wouldn't Recognize You vs Masterpiece (tie)

Voices vs FALLING FREE

 

I never found either to be terrible. They both do take some age to warm up to. A few tracks tie for me, because I couldn't drop either.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Write here...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Terms of Use