luckystar908

Yes, the 12'' version is the same as that demo (just properly mastered for release). Just like Physical Attraction Single Edit is lifted from the Demo 11-23-1982, I believe.

I had kinda forgotten how cool the American Life remixes were.
Too bad that the whole release was overshadowed by the video controversy…

I believe they are identical to the original CD. Here are the specs:

I believe they are identical to the original CD. Here are the specs:

There's a slim chance it will appear on the 'Die Another Day' EP, but there are already many mixes to include... Even the dubs are unlikely to be there.

OMG this is great!!!!!!:

This is the hidden content, please Sign In or Sign Up

It's just a joke... we all know as soon as the first reissue and tracklist are announced there will probably be some fans complaining about it, right? 
New info according to a supposedly good source on Madonna Tribe forums:
"Madonna's team are working very hard in insane levels of detail on putting together the tracklistings including some nice surprises. Rhino will just receive what M's team put together. A LOT of hard work has gone into locating specific edits and versions from very exhaustive lists for example - it will be for M to decide what actually goes out and for Rhino to decide commercially what makes sense in terms of number of physical discs (if they go down a physical product route - I have zero info on the product side of things).
I can guarantee that the track listings suggested are exhaustive."
So let's see...

The press said that Madonna fired her because she had a fling with one of her bodyguards while she was married and Kaballah forbids it, which sounds like total bullshit. 
Caresse was still quoted in the press in late 2004 about the Warner lawsuit, which she dismissed without mincing words (it's all in the Madonna VS Warner thread) and the settlement coincides with her departure which she initiated but seems to have been forced to. It seemed all of sudden because Madonna had no back up plan (she complained about having to do everything on her own because she no longer had a manager). Her sister wanted to write a book saying Kaballah forced Madonna to do it but it never happened. Especially since about that time Madonna had a rabbi at Church of Kaballah fired from their London base because he denied the Holocaust (can you believe that ? A rabbi denying the Holocaust ????) and she was starting to be very irritated by the merch at the church and other celebrities endorsing it publicly. So she had more power over the church of Kaballah than they had over her EVEN THOUGH Philip Berg did all he could to help her from divorcing.
The whole Kaballah fiasco, i say fiasco because it is, should be a whole book. They screwed her bad. They took all the money from Raising Malawi, the guy in charge Philippe van den Bossche dated Tracy Anderson, he laundered millions from the charity, that's when Madonna and Gwyneth parted because Madonna wanted her to chose between Andersona and her. She chose Anderson.
The Church of Kaballah made millions thanks to Madonna's endorsement and they screwed her. This must have really broken her and it's something we seldom talk about, both Philip and Karen Berg are dead now. Little is known about Madonna's involvment with the church today, it does not seem the Purim parties she goes to are at the Chuch or an affiliate. It's not even known if the church is still a thing. So maybe Caresse foresaw all this and tried to open Madonna's eyes. It's weird little is said about all this when Kaballah has been a huge part of Madonna's life and work for a decade. I'm very curious to know where things stand today.
 

Nice release, however they're going for home-made edits again to fit these tracks on one LP... sigh.

I didn't say "fanmade" but "home made", i.e done internally by someone other than the producer of the mix for a specific release. Tour versions are obviously a different case, and IC is completely remixed, not edited down from the original versions so that does not count. "Celebration" has home made edits, and this RSD release will do too. Nothing wrong with that though, it's just a matter of preference.

Most of these edits were not produced by the remixers for the original singles, so I consider them home-made for this release. Pretty much like some of the edits they did on FEL.

Most of these edits were not produced by the remixers for the original singles, so I consider them home-made for this release. Pretty much like some of the edits they did on FEL.

I didn't say "fanmade" but "home made", i.e done internally by someone other than the producer of the mix for a specific release. Tour versions are obviously a different case, and IC is completely remixed, not edited down from the original versions so that does not count. "Celebration" has home made edits, and this RSD release will do too. Nothing wrong with that though, it's just a matter of preference.

I have a feeling they're no longer trying to make these EPs complete, something has been missing on them since "Borderline"... Hope to be proven wrong next week

I have a feeling they're no longer trying to make these EPs complete, something has been missing on them since "Borderline"... Hope to be proven wrong next week

I have a feeling they're no longer trying to make these EPs complete, something has been missing on them since "Borderline"... Hope to be proven wrong next week

I have a feeling they're no longer trying to make these EPs complete, something has been missing on them since "Borderline"... Hope to be proven wrong next week

Keep It Together seems to be that album (just popped up on Qobuz):
https://www.qobuz.com/nz-en/album/keep-it-together-madonna/gvbmtityailla
So not the expected single...

Keep It Together seems to be that album (just popped up on Qobuz):
https://www.qobuz.com/nz-en/album/keep-it-together-madonna/gvbmtityailla
So not the expected single...

Keep It Together seems to be that album (just popped up on Qobuz):
https://www.qobuz.com/nz-en/album/keep-it-together-madonna/gvbmtityailla
So not the expected single...

I’m going to tell you… about #soon
Let’s forget the Reissues…
Forget the Bio-pic
Reinvention, Harlem, and Pride
Don’t come for me
 
In the evidence of sound issues
In the evidence of sound issues
In the evidence of sound issues
In the evidence of sound issues
 
In the demonstration of these oversights
Some have called it ridiculous 
These are not my priorities. 
 Would you like to cry?
 
 
 

I feel like they're selling this one short. There are so many remixes for the song.
But I mean...better than nothing.

I'll Remember (originally released on March 15, 1994) would be a great surprise. We still don’t have two of the mixes from digital source.

Yes, all of them are the same edit but from different transfers at different times, hence the very slight speed differences. I think the same issues happened with other older tracks too.

Tracks 1, 3 and 5 are identical to the 2001 remasters indeed.
The 7'' Edit is a tiny bit slower than the 1996 3'' CD when compared side by side, and the fade is like a second longer (you hear the last "ooh, yeah" more clearly. It's remastered.
The PA 7'' Edit looks close to the 3'' CD too, but also a tiny bit slower, although the 1987 YCD promo version is even slower (in my software at least). Not really noticeable unless you play them side by side.
Here are the 2023 version/1996 CD/1987 YCD versions of PA starting at the same time:

And the ending of each track, no longer synchronized:

It's a bit of a mess indeed!