Celebration or Broken?

[Headless.Headphones 728]

Which is the better song? Discuss

[MadonnaLove 6,216]

Celebration has good vocals and very good remixes, I love the dubs of oakenfold's and benassi's as well

[Headless.Headphones 728]

I went with Broken because of this:

 

 

But I will say before I knew of this song the video mix of Celebration was life! 

[Stevo 6,452]

I prefer Celebration TBH. I agree, remix-wise, there are some great mixes. I love the Oakenfold Remix a bit more than the album version and even the Benny Benassi mix (don't shoot me). It has a bit more energy than the album version (really, really love the guitar during the chorus!). I really like Broken and the extended versions, but prefer Celebration.

[madgefan 10,239]

Celebration  . Broken has rehashed lyrics sung over and over and over... does Madonna actually think it's funny? 

[Headless.Headphones 728]

Well she did right Over and Over; so I think she's cool with it but I just love the extended mix and where it goes lately. 

[blondebenji 2,004]

I do prefer celebration but I luv both

[o_g_c_x 2,787]

Love both

[Fighter 28,888]

Celebration  . Broken has rehashed lyrics sung over and over and over... does Madonna actually think it's funny? 

 

Broken is the one with bad lyrics? k

[Headless.Headphones 728]

After my first listen of Broken thought got the short end and "what the beep" to be honest LOL.

[madbella 596]

Broken

[geert 3,539]

Celebration

[Guest LaraCroft]

I love both tracks but i'm gonna show Broken some love for the poll.

[Turuncan 737]

You can hate me as much as you want, but I find 'Celebration' very forced and cold. 'Broken' is much better.

[MadMark 118]

Broken. Especially the Dubtronic extended version

[gafuller 1,682]

I don't care for the actual original version, I always pick the Benassi remix. So if it's the Benassi remix then I choose Celebration. If it's the original then I'll pick Broken.