Track-By-Track: Ray of Light vs Confessions

[LindebergBoy 1,449]

Drowned World/Substitute for Love vs Hung Up

Swim vs Get Together

Ray of Light vs Sorry

Candy Perfume Girl vs Future Lovers

Skin vs I Love New York

Nothing Really Matters vs Let It Will Be

Sky Fits Heaven vs Forbidden Love

Shanti/Ashtangi vs Jump

Frozen vs How High

The Power of Goodbye vs Isaac 

To Have and Not to Hold vs Push

Little Star vs Like It or Not

Mer Girl vs Fighting Spirit

[Nick 2,398]

Drowned World/Substitute for Love vs Hung Up
Swim vs Get Together
Ray of Light vs Sorry
Candy Perfume Girl vs Future Lovers
Skin vs I Love New York
Nothing Really Matters vs Let It Will Be
Sky Fits Heaven vs Forbidden Love
Shanti/Ashtangi vs Jump
Frozen vs How High
The Power of Goodbye vs Isaac
To Have and Not to Hold vs Push
Little Star vs Like It or Not
Mer Girl vs Fighting Spirit

 

Some really tough choices here!

[RebelHeart 752]

Drowned World/Substitute for Love vs Hung Up

Swim vs Get Together

Ray of Light vs Sorry

Candy Perfume Girl vs Future Lovers

Skin vs I Love New York

Nothing Really Matters vs Let It Will Be

Sky Fits Heaven vs Forbidden Love

Shanti/Ashtangi vs Jump

Frozen vs How High

The Power of Goodbye vs Isaac 

To Have and Not to Hold vs Push

Little Star vs Like It or Not

Mer Girl vs Fighting Spirit

 

ROL: 5 COADF: 8

[RUADJAI 16,029]

Since these albums are kinda structured differently I feel like they should be pitted against each other based on singles first. 

 

ROL                                           Confessions

 

Frozen                                       Hung Up

Ray of Light                               Sorry

Drowned World                         Get Together

Power of Goodbye                    Jump

Nothing Really Matters              Future Lovers

Swim                                         I Love New York

Candy Perfume Girl                   Let it Will Be

Skin                                           Forbidden Love

Sky Fits Heaven                        How High

Shanti                                        Issac

To Have and Not to Hold          Push

Little Star                                  Like it or Not

Mer Girl                                     Fighting Spirit 

[carlito76 19]

Drowned World/Substitute for Love vs Hung Up

Swim vs Get Together

Ray of Light vs Sorry

Candy Perfume Girl vs Future Lovers

Skin vs I Love New York

Nothing Really Matters vs Let It Will Be

Sky Fits Heaven vs Forbidden Love

Shanti/Ashtangi vs Jump

Frozen vs How High

The Power of Goodbye vs Isaac 

To Have and Not to Hold vs Push

Little Star vs Like It or Not

Mer Girl vs Fighting Spirit

[James19709 373]

Skim DESTROYS I love New York

 

Wish she'd used Triggering Your Senses instead tbh.

[tifenn 99]

Drowned World/Substitute for Love vs Hung Up

Swim vs Get Together

Ray of Light vs Sorry

Candy Perfume Girl vs Future Lovers

Skin vs I Love New York

Nothing Really Matters vs Let It Will Be (very difficult choice)

Sky Fits Heaven vs Forbidden Love

Shanti/Ashtangi vs Jump

Frozen vs How High

The Power of Goodbye vs Isaac 

To Have and Not to Hold vs Push

Little Star vs Like It or Not

Mer Girl vs Fighting Spirit

[Turuncan 737]

Drowned World/Substitute for Love vs Hung Up

Swim vs Get Together

Ray of Light vs Sorry

Candy Perfume Girl vs Future Lovers

Skin vs I Love New York

Nothing Really Matters vs Let It Will Be

Sky Fits Heaven vs Forbidden Love

Shanti/Ashtangi vs Jump

Frozen vs How High (wow, poor 'How High'!)

The Power of Good-Bye vs Isaac

To Have and Not to Hold vs Push

Little Star vs Like It or Not

Mer Girl vs Fighting Spirit

 

"Ray of Light": 8

"Confessions on a Dance Floor": 5

[MadMark 118]

Drowned World/Substitute for Love vs Hung Up

Swim vs Get Together

Ray of Light vs Sorry

Candy Perfume Girl vs Future Lovers

Skin vs I Love New York

Nothing Really Matters vs Let It Will Be

Sky Fits Heaven vs Forbidden Love

Shanti/Ashtangi vs Jump

Frozen vs How High

The Power of Goodbye vs Isaac 

To Have and Not to Hold vs Push

Little Star vs Like It or Not

Mer Girl vs Fighting Spirit

 

 

Both are not my favorite Madonna albums but it was pretty easy for me

[madbella 596]

Drowned World/Substitute for Love vs Hung Up

Swim vs Get Together

Ray of Light vs Sorry

Candy Perfume Girl vs Future Lovers

Skin vs I Love New York

Nothing Really Matters vs Let It Will Be

Sky Fits Heaven vs Forbidden Love

Shanti/Ashtangi vs Jump

Frozen vs How High 

The Power of Good-Bye vs Isaac

To Have and Not to Hold vs Push

Little Star vs Like It or Not

Mer Girl vs Fighting Spirit

 

"Ray of Light": 7

"Confessions on a Dance Floor": 6