anel_

I mean thief of hearts, words are in the top 3 along with secret garden
Imo thrift of heats and words is better because it has that demo sound. To me it's aged well

Did you do it is a great track. I love that "clean up my riffle" part. Genius. 

Us fans know that Erotica is one of Madonna's most compelling work of art. It stands the test of time, broke so many boundaries and the songs are incredile
However this album unfortunately isn't critically acclaimed the way LAP, ROL and COADF are. Imo Erotica arguably in some way could be her best album. It's fantastic from start to finish. She only worked consistently with 2 producers on it Andre Betts and Shep Pettibone (being a co producer herself) wrote the songs along with Shep and Andre, she also managed to keep a continuing narrative story going through the album, especially with waiting/thief of hearts/words (Madonna's best song trilogy)
I understand that back in 1992 realeaisng an album like Erotica was dangerous and risky as fuck BUT in 2018 it isn't. This album should be revalued (more than what it already has been in the last few years). Rolling Stones still haven't placed it in the 500 greatest albums of all time and it absolutely deserves a spot in that list. Not just Rolling Stone magazine but Im using it as a primary example
Who agrees and disagrees? 

Us fans know that Erotica is one of Madonna's most compelling work of art. It stands the test of time, broke so many boundaries and the songs are incredile
However this album unfortunately isn't critically acclaimed the way LAP, ROL and COADF are. Imo Erotica arguably in some way could be her best album. It's fantastic from start to finish. She only worked consistently with 2 producers on it Andre Betts and Shep Pettibone (being a co producer herself) wrote the songs along with Shep and Andre, she also managed to keep a continuing narrative story going through the album, especially with waiting/thief of hearts/words (Madonna's best song trilogy)
I understand that back in 1992 realeaisng an album like Erotica was dangerous and risky as fuck BUT in 2018 it isn't. This album should be revalued (more than what it already has been in the last few years). Rolling Stones still haven't placed it in the 500 greatest albums of all time and it absolutely deserves a spot in that list. Not just Rolling Stone magazine but Im using it as a primary example
Who agrees and disagrees? 

Us fans know that Erotica is one of Madonna's most compelling work of art. It stands the test of time, broke so many boundaries and the songs are incredile
However this album unfortunately isn't critically acclaimed the way LAP, ROL and COADF are. Imo Erotica arguably in some way could be her best album. It's fantastic from start to finish. She only worked consistently with 2 producers on it Andre Betts and Shep Pettibone (being a co producer herself) wrote the songs along with Shep and Andre, she also managed to keep a continuing narrative story going through the album, especially with waiting/thief of hearts/words (Madonna's best song trilogy)
I understand that back in 1992 realeaisng an album like Erotica was dangerous and risky as fuck BUT in 2018 it isn't. This album should be revalued (more than what it already has been in the last few years). Rolling Stones still haven't placed it in the 500 greatest albums of all time and it absolutely deserves a spot in that list. Not just Rolling Stone magazine but Im using it as a primary example
Who agrees and disagrees? 

Us fans know that Erotica is one of Madonna's most compelling work of art. It stands the test of time, broke so many boundaries and the songs are incredile
However this album unfortunately isn't critically acclaimed the way LAP, ROL and COADF are. Imo Erotica arguably in some way could be her best album. It's fantastic from start to finish. She only worked consistently with 2 producers on it Andre Betts and Shep Pettibone (being a co producer herself) wrote the songs along with Shep and Andre, she also managed to keep a continuing narrative story going through the album, especially with waiting/thief of hearts/words (Madonna's best song trilogy)
I understand that back in 1992 realeaisng an album like Erotica was dangerous and risky as fuck BUT in 2018 it isn't. This album should be revalued (more than what it already has been in the last few years). Rolling Stones still haven't placed it in the 500 greatest albums of all time and it absolutely deserves a spot in that list. Not just Rolling Stone magazine but Im using it as a primary example
Who agrees and disagrees? 

Us fans know that Erotica is one of Madonna's most compelling work of art. It stands the test of time, broke so many boundaries and the songs are incredile
However this album unfortunately isn't critically acclaimed the way LAP, ROL and COADF are. Imo Erotica arguably in some way could be her best album. It's fantastic from start to finish. She only worked consistently with 2 producers on it Andre Betts and Shep Pettibone (being a co producer herself) wrote the songs along with Shep and Andre, she also managed to keep a continuing narrative story going through the album, especially with waiting/thief of hearts/words (Madonna's best song trilogy)
I understand that back in 1992 realeaisng an album like Erotica was dangerous and risky as fuck BUT in 2018 it isn't. This album should be revalued (more than what it already has been in the last few years). Rolling Stones still haven't placed it in the 500 greatest albums of all time and it absolutely deserves a spot in that list. Not just Rolling Stone magazine but Im using it as a primary example
Who agrees and disagrees? 

Us fans know that Erotica is one of Madonna's most compelling work of art. It stands the test of time, broke so many boundaries and the songs are incredile
However this album unfortunately isn't critically acclaimed the way LAP, ROL and COADF are. Imo Erotica arguably in some way could be her best album. It's fantastic from start to finish. She only worked consistently with 2 producers on it Andre Betts and Shep Pettibone (being a co producer herself) wrote the songs along with Shep and Andre, she also managed to keep a continuing narrative story going through the album, especially with waiting/thief of hearts/words (Madonna's best song trilogy)
I understand that back in 1992 realeaisng an album like Erotica was dangerous and risky as fuck BUT in 2018 it isn't. This album should be revalued (more than what it already has been in the last few years). Rolling Stones still haven't placed it in the 500 greatest albums of all time and it absolutely deserves a spot in that list. Not just Rolling Stone magazine but Im using it as a primary example
Who agrees and disagrees? 

Erotica* is a masterpiece

Erotica* is a masterpiece

Us fans know that Erotica is one of Madonna's most compelling work of art. It stands the test of time, broke so many boundaries and the songs are incredile
However this album unfortunately isn't critically acclaimed the way LAP, ROL and COADF are. Imo Erotica arguably in some way could be her best album. It's fantastic from start to finish. She only worked consistently with 2 producers on it Andre Betts and Shep Pettibone (being a co producer herself) wrote the songs along with Shep and Andre, she also managed to keep a continuing narrative story going through the album, especially with waiting/thief of hearts/words (Madonna's best song trilogy)
I understand that back in 1992 realeaisng an album like Erotica was dangerous and risky as fuck BUT in 2018 it isn't. This album should be revalued (more than what it already has been in the last few years). Rolling Stones still haven't placed it in the 500 greatest albums of all time and it absolutely deserves a spot in that list. Not just Rolling Stone magazine but Im using it as a primary example
Who agrees and disagrees? 

Us fans know that Erotica is one of Madonna's most compelling work of art. It stands the test of time, broke so many boundaries and the songs are incredile
However this album unfortunately isn't critically acclaimed the way LAP, ROL and COADF are. Imo Erotica arguably in some way could be her best album. It's fantastic from start to finish. She only worked consistently with 2 producers on it Andre Betts and Shep Pettibone (being a co producer herself) wrote the songs along with Shep and Andre, she also managed to keep a continuing narrative story going through the album, especially with waiting/thief of hearts/words (Madonna's best song trilogy)
I understand that back in 1992 realeaisng an album like Erotica was dangerous and risky as fuck BUT in 2018 it isn't. This album should be revalued (more than what it already has been in the last few years). Rolling Stones still haven't placed it in the 500 greatest albums of all time and it absolutely deserves a spot in that list. Not just Rolling Stone magazine but Im using it as a primary example
Who agrees and disagrees? 

I agree that most of her albums should be in that list. She knows how to make an excellent album from start to finish. MDNA is another underrated album but more amongst the fans. I feel like MDNA will one day be appreciated

THIS IS GOING TO BE FUN FOR ALL OF YOU I ASSUME! 
ONE OF HER BEST AND ARGUABLY HER BEST!
This albums hold her best non single song - secret garden
1. Erotica
2. Fever
3. Bye Bye Baby
4. Deeper and Deeper
5. Where Life Begins
6. Bad Girl
7. Waiting
8. Thief of Hearts
9. Words
10. Rain
11. Why’s it so Hard
12. In this Life
13. Did you Do it?
14. Secret Garden

THIS IS GOING TO BE FUN FOR ALL OF YOU I ASSUME! 
ONE OF HER BEST AND ARGUABLY HER BEST!
This albums hold her best non single song - secret garden
1. Erotica
2. Fever
3. Bye Bye Baby
4. Deeper and Deeper
5. Where Life Begins
6. Bad Girl
7. Waiting
8. Thief of Hearts
9. Words
10. Rain
11. Why’s it so Hard
12. In this Life
13. Did you Do it?
14. Secret Garden

Will there be a thread where we rank the songs on American Life?

Honestly, one of Madonna’s best albums. This album is fantastic! Madonna’s work of art. No other words needed. Rank the tracks from least to most favourite. Also, can we just admit that this albums holds Madonna’s best ballads!!!? Oh father is amazing! This is gonna be fun x
1. Like a Prayer
2. Express Yourself
3. Love Song
4. Til Death Do us Part
5. Promise to Try
6. Cherish
7. Dear Jessie
8. Oh Father
9. Keep it Together
10. Pray for Spanish Eyes
11. Act of Contrition

1. Erotica
1. Fever
1. Bye Bye Baby
1. Deeper and Deeper
1. Where Life Begins
1. Bad Girl
1. Waiting
1. Thief of Hearts
1. Words
1. Rain
1. Why’s it so Hard
1. In this Life
1. Did you Do it?
1. Secret Garden
 
I'M SORRY, I CAN'T RANK THEM. Huhuhu

DONT STOP IS ONE OF HER BEST NON SINGLE TRACKS WOW

Guys I thought i’d Be fun and spontaneous by getting everyone to come together and rank their least to most favourite songs from each album. This can be a fun lead up activity while we wait for the 14th album by the queen. Let’s start with the first album. I hope everyone enjoys this as much as I will (ps I know this is going to be hard and I’ll post my ranking soon in the comments)
1. Lucky star
2. Borderline
3. Burning up
4. I Know It
5. Holiday
6. Think of Me
7. Physical Attraction 
8. Everybody
 
 

1. American Life
2. Ray of Light
3. Music
4. Confessions on a Dance Floor
5. Hard Candy

This is true.

Erotica* is a masterpiece

I don’t know where you hear poor production and why you think it’s dated but that’s your opinion. But just so you know the album was meant to have a raw, demo, unfinished sound to it and it’s a very daring album

Erotica* is a masterpiece