4 Minutes Vs. Give Me All Your Luvin'

[Headless.Headphones 728]

Go!

[gafuller 1,697]

??? Why would you do this! I cannot vote on this one. Both are very nostalgic for me in different ways. 4 Minutes was the first song of hers that I'd heard since Music (I was probably 13 when 4 Minutes came out) and was actively aware of just having coming out. Give Me All Your Luvin' was like mine and my best friends go-to anthem in our Sophomore year. Both are great, though some or many may disagree.

[wtg1987 10,677]

What if you hate either song though ?(Like i do ?) well i do like the rebirth remix of 4 minutes only so i will vote for that i guess - production wise its been downhill since 4 minutes :(( (With the exception of Falling Free)

[Headless.Headphones 728]

I picked them because both are the lead singles to an album that is mostly luke warm to everyone.

[Headless.Headphones 728]

What if you hate either song though ?(Like i do ?) well i do like the rebirth remix of 4 minutes only so i will vote for that i guess - production wise its been downhill since 4 minutes :(( (With the exception of Falling Free)

 

I never put a neither option but liking the remix won't count lol.

[Nick 2,398]

4 Minutes for sure. Just overall a better song in my opinion, and the remixes are better than the GMAYL ones (not to say that they're bad, just 4 Minutes is better ;) )

[Turuncan 737]

One is a fully realized, catchy song that did well on the charts as well.

 

The other is a big fat joke that alienated the potential to her long-awaited (then) new album.

 

Guess which one I chose!

[Fighter 28,889]

Very hard to choose cos neither is great.

 

I'd say Give Me All Your Luvin' cos it's fun without feeling so random. 4 Minutes is all instrumental. 

[Xander 430]

I chose Give Me All Your Luvin' because of the two I think it is the more energetic and fun song. I hate the edit of 4 Minutes that played on radio and showed up on Celebration which is barely over 3 minutes long--it just seems silly to me to have a song called 4 minutes and have it be less than that, so much so that it's basically 3 minutes long. That being said, I appreciate the statement that she tried to make with the song 4 Minutes on her save-the-world kick, and the music video, which I thought she looked stunning in. 

[dav_fer 200]

I loved Give me all your luvin' video, so I would pick that song!

[migsou 1,109]

"4 minutes" all the way. what's with the hate on "hard candy"? at least it sounds like a real album - not a mess like "rebel heart"

[MadMark 118]

@@migsou - true

[geert 3,636]

4 Minutes

[MadMark 118]

4 Minutes of course.

Great duett and Timbaland gave one of his best productions ever.

Grammy award nominated song and mega hit all over the world