The ranking of Madonna’s lead singles

[Turuncan 737]

Idolator ranked Madonna’s lead singles off each of her studio album from best to worst.

https://www.idolator.com/7752032/madonna-14-lead-singles-ranked?view-all&ios=1

It is as follows:

1. Like a Prayer

2. Hung Up

3. Frozen 

4. Live to Tell

5. Music

6. Secret

7. Erotica 

8. Like a Virgin

9. 4 Minutes

10. Medellín

11. Living for Love

12. Everybody

13. American Life

14. Give Me All Your Luvin’

 

Do you agree with the list?

For my own account, I would rank ‘4 Minutes’ and ‘Living for Love’ higher than ‘Erotica’ and ‘Like a Virgin’, and ‘Secret’ higher than ‘Music’. I agree with the rest.

[CYSMM 696]

American Life is an amazing song but not a good lead single...

Give Me all Your Love is nice too hear but that song isn't iconic at all

Medellin is nice but a bit banal

Living For Love miss something as a lead single

Hung Up, Music, 4 Minutes , Like A Prayer, Like A Virgin are anthem

Erotica and Frozen is innovative

Live To Tell I've never been a huge fan of that song

Secret is a good song underrated

 

[Dazedmadonna 18,531]

For me Give Me All Your Luvin', Celebration and Living For Love are her worst lead singles EVER.

Also, can't consider 'Live To Tell' the lead single to True Blue as for me the real lead is 'Papa Don't Preach'

[GhostOrchid 706]

2 hours ago, Dazedmadonna said:

For me Give Me All Your Luvin', Celebration and Living For Love are her worst lead singles EVER.

Also, can't consider 'Live To Tell' the lead single to True Blue as for me the real lead is 'Papa Don't Preach'

True, Live to Tell was not promoting the album, I also wouldn't count Everybody as the lead single from Madonna either, it's Holiday.

[MrCommotion 563]

Ehh Medellín should be over Secret at least. It's better than 4 Minutes too