VogueMusic

Tbh I’m just over these conversations for good... it’s just boring to keep on arguing. M is not overrated nor underrated... she’s just an artist from 80’s which happened to continue her passion till our current time. Like any other artist in the industry she had her ups & downs. & YouTube views didn’t existed until late 00’s. Let’s see who’s actually winning is our current time?? None... ?

You don't become the most successful female artist in the history of popular music by hype alone. Period.
 

You don't become the most successful female artist in the history of popular music by hype alone. Period.
 

You don't become the most successful female artist in the history of popular music by hype alone. Period.
 

You don't become the most successful female artist in the history of popular music by hype alone. Period.
 

You don't become the most successful female artist in the history of popular music by hype alone. Period.
 

You don't become the most successful female artist in the history of popular music by hype alone. Period.
 

You don't become the most successful female artist in the history of popular music by hype alone. Period.
 

You don't become the most successful female artist in the history of popular music by hype alone. Period.
 

You don't become the most successful female artist in the history of popular music by hype alone. Period.
 

You don't become the most successful female artist in the history of popular music by hype alone. Period.
 

You don't become the most successful female artist in the history of popular music by hype alone. Period.
 

You don't become the most successful female artist in the history of popular music by hype alone. Period.
 

You don't become the most successful female artist in the history of popular music by hype alone. Period.
 

Ive been poor ever since ive been a fan lol .. So 36 years lol

I would argue we haven't had a good career spanning GH since...well, "The Immaculate Collection", and even that was 15 remixes basically. Saying compilations aren't selling, or that anyone can make a Madonna hits collection on Spotify... both false. Most of Madonna's single edits aren't available anywhere to stream, and you can check my topic on Single Edits to see how many of them are missing exactly. I'd say approx 80%. And compilations are still a chart staple, they sell really well, and yeah, it's probably an older generation, but that's an underrated demographic. 
So yeah, a well done and well thought of Greatest Hits would be more than welcome. I'm especially opposed to any reworkings, especially with the current state of her voice. We gotta pitch down "Lucky Star" 4 semitones or something!

Geez, she can't win, can she? On the one hand, fans always complain how she doesn't respect, honour or even acknowledge her legacy and her back catalog (nothing for 20 years of Ray of Light, nothing for 30 years of True Blue, a playlist for 30 years of Like A Prayer, etc). Greatest Hits can be a great way of doing do that - given that it's done right of course. At the moment there really isn't a comprehensive Madonna greatest hits package - Celebration was a poorly executed attempt at that but it fell shortly, both in terms of songs included/excluded and its quality.