Game: + and - of Madonna Songs

[devilpray 2,390]

What's the next song?

 

shit, i always forget that

[Winn 2,358]

Wash All Over Me:

 

Positive: Strings in the demo were perfection.

Negative: The strings were taken out or buried so deep in the official

 

Next song: What It Feels Like For A Girl

[Winn 2,358]

This is a fun game!

[MXRXNCHX 1,133]

What It Feels Like For A Girl

 

Positive: All of it, including the cover for the single

 

Negative: Instead of the Above & Beyond remix, they should have used the original for the music video (imagine all that wreckage with that sweet tune as the background music)

 

Up next we have Oh Father

[mr00mister 902]

Oh Father

 

positive: absolutely everything. it's maybe one of the best songs off Like A Prayer. since the beginning, to her raw performance (you can actually feel M breaking down in tears as she sings), to the instrumentation, the orchestra... and how it breaks your heart from the happiness built from "Dear Jessie"

 

(ok, story time. i feel this song beyond a personal level, because my girlfriend's mother died when she was 4, and basically her dad treats her the same way Mr. Ciccone treated 'Nonni' back on the day)

 

negative: is there anything bad about this song?

 

since we're at that...

next song: Dear Jessie

[survivalartist 6,745]

Dear Jessie 

 

Positives: The video! Fucking adorable. The music is really adorable too, I love how it turns to a waltz in the middle. 

 

Negative: Not sure what any of it means.

 

Next: Your Honesty

[MerBoy13 595]

Your Honesty

 

Positive: Great song the french part is orgasmic.

 

Negative: Why wasn't it put on Bedtime Stories?

 

Next: Shame

[Winn 2,358]

lol Shame?

 

Positive: I'm positive I never heard of it.

Negative: It appears to have had  little impact on even M's hardcore listening audience.

 

Next up: Hung up

[MXRXNCHX 1,133]

This is a hard one 

 

Hung Up

 

Positive: Every single thing. The music, the lyrics, the singing, the music video, the performances, the cover for the single, the remixes (SDP's one is my favorite)

 

Negative: 5 minutes aren't enough (I love long songs, so yeah...)

 

 

Mmmm...The next one is Human Nature

[InfinityWithin 278]

Human Nature

 

Positive: This is MY Madonna song!   Its lyrics are fearless and ironic, the beats are deep and funky, the chorus vocals are gorgeous,  the video is minimalistic, the choreography amazing... LOVE, LOVE, LOVE it!

 

Negative: The dance mixes with her sped up vocals.   WHYYYY?????

 

Next: Spanish Lessons

[Jorick 1,497]

Spannish Lesson + the bee "zooming" sound.- Everything but the bee "zooming" sound.Next up: I Fucked Up

[MXRXNCHX 1,133]

I Fucked Up

 

Positive: The lyrics and the dark feeling at parts of the songNegative: A pretty forgettable track, to be honest

 

 

One of my personal favorites, next is I Want You

[devilpray 2,390]

I Want You

 

Positive: my favorite m cover, the beat and her vocal delivery are sooooo hunting. 

 

Negative: she never performed this live.

 

Next: Beat Goes On

[mr00mister 902]

Beat Goes On:

 

positive: oh wow! what a song! it's so incredible, a great dance tune, and also, very motivating... it's the same theme we saw on "Jump" (only you can move yourself forward). the keyboard on the second chorus really makes the song.

 

negative: remember the rumours of this one being a Hard Candy single? it would have been great. 

 

next song: Devil Wouldn't Recognize You

[Winn 2,358]

Devil Wouldn't Recognize You

 

Positive: I don't typically go for ballads but I love this one. Lush live performance, pretty melody, it just has a smooth yet bouncy vibe. One of my favorites from Hard Candy.

 

Negative: No remixes and it never became a single.

 

Next: Shanti Ashtangi

[survivalartist 6,745]

Shanti AshtangiPositive - So much is going on ar once and somehow its peaceful. Orbit top notch performance. Very trippy! Fun to work out to.Negative - It is one to try to sing along to or hum and it just sounds a mess. Jahaneuh? No offense intended regarding this pop song.Next - Forbidden Love from Bedtime Stories (sidebar years ago a random girl slayed this song at karoke night. i wish i had taped it.)

[MerBoy13 595]

lol Shame?  Positive: I'm positive I never heard of it.Negative: It appears to have had  little impact on even M's hardcore listening audience. Next up: Hung up

It's a demo from Erotica it leaked last August or around that time.

[InfinityWithin 278]

FORBIDDEN LOVE

 

+ Great song, great production, nice husky voice. And I love the whispering Babyface! "Don't go near the fire...".

 

- A remix would have been nice! And a live performance.

 

Next: WHERE LIFE BEGINS

[Jorick 1,497]

Where Life Begins + a great jazzy feeling ode to oral sex.- Song is too long. Next up: voices

[MeantToBeIconic 999]

Voices

 

Positive: "Are you walking the dog?... Is that dog walking you?" Pretty much that whole bit.

 

Negative: The bass was not mastered correctly, but it muffles the song on the beats. No ma'am, won't have it.

 

 

Next: Mer Girl

[MXRXNCHX 1,133]

Mer GirlPositive: The lyrics are amazing! I love how the song starts and how it ends and how it's beatless (you know what I mean)

 

Negative: Criminally underrated.

 

 

Next we have Dress You Up

 

 

* gotta ask, why can't we do this with the remixes? :( *

[MeantToBeIconic 999]

 

* gotta ask, why can't we do this with the remixes? :( *

 

I guess you could, I just don'w want people to get mixed up. If you make sure people know you're referencing a remix and which one, go for it

[MXRXNCHX 1,133]

I guess you could, I just don'w want people to get mixed up. If you make sure people know you're referencing a remix and which one, go for it

 

Gotcha

[Jorick 1,497]

Dress You Up+ Great eighties song, love the overall vibe of this one. Love the remix edit even more.- Totally ruined the song at the S&S tour 2009. What a mess?Next up: Like a Prayer /S&S Remix

[MXRXNCHX 1,133]

Like A Prayer (S&S Remix)

 

Positive: How fast it goes, you can even workout to it

 

Negative: Speaking for myself, it's not a remix that I would listen more than once in a day

 

 

Keeping the remix trend, Express Yourself (Shep's Spressin' Himself Re-Remix)