Candy Perfume Girl or Candy Shop?

[Voguerista 13,331]

It's the battle of the "candy's" now. Which do you prefer more?

 

I love both, but, I'll give the edge to "Candy Shop"!!

[groovyguy 63,869]

Luv both but I give the edge to Candy Perfume Girl. But I also really love the MDNA version of Candy Shop.

[Voguerista 13,331]

Luv both but I give the edge to Candy Perfume Girl. But I also really love the MDNA version of Candy Shop.

 

DIES! ME TOO!!! 

[Voguerista 13,331]

Oh no, I have to watch this again now... 

 

[groovyguy 63,869]

^ That version is sick! It's one of the highlights of the MDNA tour for me.

[Voguerista 13,331]

SAME!!!!!

[groovyguy 63,869]

^ We share the same excellent taste! 

[Guest]

Like what she did with Candy Shop on MDNA, but it's one of my least favs on the HARD CANDY album. Candy Perfume Girl obviously wins for me. The two songs do not even compare at the least. Candy Perfume GIrl was something totally different that we haven't heard. Candy Shop sounds too much like a lot of the recyle R&B/Hip Hop sounds we've been getting for years.

[NowRadiate 3,334]

i love the MDNA version of Candy Shop (especially the string arrangement) but Candy Perfume Girl is a win for me. i agree with Liam.

[unapologeticheart 872]

Candy perfume girl wins. Especially the live performance

 

[Halex 1,615]

Candy Perfume Girl. 

The first live performance by RockDonna ♥

[BringUrLUV 1,114]

Candy Shop definitely!  My fav version has to be the S&S Live version though.  Album version is a bit boring.  MDNA version was fantastic too!

[Laura25 85]

Candy Perfume Girl for sure.

 

But the live version on MDNA won me over with Candy Shop. I wasn't a huge fan of it on the album, but there's always a song like that on each tour for me where the live version wins me over 

[Fighter 28,888]

I like Candy Perfume Girl but I do like Candy Shop. Funny back then I thought it was weak but now the memories make me love it, especially the performance at the S&S 2009 with the cooler new outfit and hair and marilyn minter backdrop. 

[cindy_ve 800]

I hated both , but start to love Candy shop sinds the opening of the promo Tour i fell in love with the dance and song

[PlayPause 2,891]

.

[MattyMads 5,707]

Candyshop loved the performances on S&S and MDNA

 

Erotic Candyshop is just amazing 

[Halex 1,615]

Candy perfume girl wins. Especially the live performance

Same here

[LZE 468]

same here

 

Candy perfume girl wins. Especially the live performance

 

[cindy_ve 800]

same here

i always skipp this song on the cd and dvd

[Yung Rapunxel 2,191]

Candy Perfume Girl

[ShantiAshtangi 257]

Candy Perfume Girl. By miles better than CS (imho) …

[Breathless 5,286]

Candy Perfume Girl all the way!!

[unapologeticheart 872]

i always skipp this song on the cd and dvd

I personnally wouldn't mind if her next tour is 100% like that

[luckystar 728]

Candy Perfume Girl.

 

Candy Shop is a mess, that Madonna should perform  only at her home.

 

Recently I had a dream where Madonna performed Candy Shop on her new tour. It was a reinvented and very different version that vowed everybody.