GhostOrchid

she did look fab throughout that whole era, esp. during the tour.

Why isn't Turn Off The Radio called yet??

I didn't rate it this low, but I'm always happy to see a FAKE fail. Burn bitch (evil laugh)

Well it sets me in the right mood for the day

This bitch should have been #16. Bday song is crappy but at least you know you'll play it once a year.

Was just thinking, this has to be the biggest number of zeroes so far

Voted! I hate to admit that today this album sounds as lifeless and forced as it did the first time I heard it, with a few honorable exceptions. Clearly she had other things on her mind and the label people should have just let her finish her movie first. Luckily, she redeemed herself with the tour which is one of her best!

So I finally decided that 50-track is the main version (for me). Mainly because of the interview she gave to V Magazine where she talks about it, and promotes that version. I also realized that 16-track is just something she put together as a gift to the Gays for Pride so that they have something to blast over their speakers for a few days. Or, you can view it as a trailer before the real thing. And finally because the results here were so overwhelmingly in favour of the 3CD (95% to 5%). Thanks to everyone who voted and shared their two cents!

What Mr. Brainwash did for Celebration album graphics was fierce and iconic. This is a literal rip-off and a cheep one too. Don't understand why they had to go with the same concept twice.

Do we know when and where were these photos shot and are they exclusive to this issue? By Ricardo Gomes I assume?

right. so it can chart then. this is from prince's wikipedia: "Though not a major seller, it did sell over 500,000 copies. Being three discs, it was qualified to being certified double platinum"

the 3CD will probably not be eligible to chart -at least the physical copies, but the streaming will help boost her position

It does make sense that the 16-track is for general public and non-fans, but can 3CD even be considered an album? i think I read somewhere that up to 2CDs is an album and anything 3+ is a box set.

this is not helpful because they really can be viewed as separate albums and they both have a concept. The 16 track is a number 1 from each era, plus if you get the vinyl then each side covers one decade. but the 50 track is all of the number ones from the billboard chart. and the title implies that she finally got enough love with 50 number ones. so i guess that is the main one. although i prefer the concept and artwork of the 16 track. this is not as easy as deciding which Madame X or Rebel Heart or Celebration version is the main one.

I can't decide if 1 CD is the shortened version or the 3CD is the expanded version. What do you guys think?

Which version do you guys consider to be the main version of Finally Enough Love - the 1CD or the 3 CD?

I'm sure there are a lot of Russian fans here who don't deserve to be nuked because of one deranged leader, and they probably feel awful reading this.

I know we can base our ratings on a version of a song we prefer, but we should specify whether Give Me All Your Luvin' is the Original or Party Rock version? For me it could be either a 0 or a 10

I'm just completely and utterly shocked that It's So Cool was so low. That was my personal song of the year back in 2009, not just by Madonna but literally out of all the songs released that year. btw, is this the first time that a non-single wins?

I thought Jump would be the third one because the hype sticker said "includes Sorry and Jump"

I gave it a 5 - ranks 10th on my list. And i wasn't spamming, there literally were 9 songs on this album I thought were better. I never could understand the obsession and the universal acclaim

Can't wait to see how Candy Shop does, it can literally go either way. I think people will be giving it an 11 out of a joke and then you're all gonna cry why Give it 2 Me doesn't win.

Wow so close! 9.23, 9.25

Well done!! Whichever song wins I'm glad this was top 3

I feel like they put the video concept together in 3 minutes. She was probably like, "Jonas, you have an hour. The show is about to start"