antigulag

was Peter gay? his club 69 albums always had really gay artwork.

Terrible revisionistic article justifying her bs excuses.

couldn't be more wrong.

don't know what you are talking about but you sound like a stooge threatened by free speech.

my account may be a newbie but my brain is not. Billboard is a garbage publication that had zero credibility today. So sad that you cannot decide for yourself and has to follow whatever crap Billboard peddles.

do you mean that Masterpiece wasn't good enough? Masterpiece couldn't be nominated to the Oscars because it didn't follow the nomination requisites, a HUGE BLUNDER, that falls square on HER camp.

just because you've been bullied into thinking he's hot doesn't mean he isn't ugly as f*ck. But most importantly, he's incompetent ad f*ck, no matter how many millions he has.

that's how they work TODAY. Not back then.

This is a revisionist article. Many Madonna fans have grown up and became reporters and now peddle The Dictums: "Erotica is her best album", "American Life was a huge controversy", "Confessions is her most successful era", "She liberated society from sex shame". These new fan reporters working in the media are as fake and as lying as all the 80's and 90's writers who tried to maliciously convince the public that she wasn't talented. They are no different.

You're wrong. Agree to disagree.

That's because the Live to Tell and MDNA controversies later, threatened her life and family but not her sales 😂😂😂😂

You are just repeating and parroting the narrative dictum. What happened to the Dixie Chicks was nowhere near Madonna's situation, nobody cared about the video as they did with what the Dixie Chicks said, which I have to say, the Dixie Chicks are not famous outside of America. There was no reason for her to pull a worldwide release for what happened to the Dixie Chicks, specially when everyone knew the video lampooned war criminal Bush before it even got released and it did not generate the backlash the Dixie Chicks did. Madonna and the fan community rabidly hate American conservatives but when it comes to American Life you all sound like priests bowing down to the sacrosant figure of war criminal Bush. The things Madonna does now, how she defiles the American presidency and saying she wanted to bomb it, rhetorical I know but an insanely crass comment, just doesn't make sense when contrasted with the constant reverance to her ill-fated decision of not releasing American Life in order to "not offend".

She could have sent all the profits of the single to the veterans. Better yet, release a video single and give the profits to the veterans. There was no reason to pull the video. She did it out of cynical self-preservation, a constant in her life, it just so happens that this time it ended her career.

If she wanted to protest the war there was no better time than releasing the video when she was going to. Her explanations for pulling it do not make sense and never did.

There have been many fake Madonna narratives throughout the years and the most persistant is that "everyone was oppressed in the 80's and 90's, I was persecuted for being a woman, I had to release SEX to liberate everyone and I got punished" she pushes that to this day and it is an absolute cardinal sin to even question it among fans but it is all bullshit. Also, American Life is her second Erotica. She was delusional in both and it lead to career ending consequences. She barely survived the first one, she didn't the second one.