[Madonna Song, This or That Game!]

Ring My Bell

Where Life Begins or Heartbeat? 

[Madonna Song, This or That Game!]

Devil Pray

True Blue or What It Feels Like for a Girl?

[Madonna Song, This or That Game!]

Crazy for You

Thief of Hearts or She's Not Me?

[Madonna Song, This or That Game!]

White Heat

Inside of Me or Nobody's Perfect? 

[Madonna Song, This or That Game!]

Act of Contrition

Promise to Try or Something to Remember? 

[Madonna Song, This or That Game!]

Love Makes the World Go 'Round

I'm Going Bananas or Did You Do It?

[Madonna Song, This or That Game!]

Like a Virgin

In This Life or Gone? 

[Erotica 30th Anniversary October 20th, 2022]

This has always been one of my favorite Madonna albums. I bought it maybe about 10 years ago and I was instantly hooked into it. In my opinion, Deeper and Deeper is one of the best songs she's ever done - the lyrics are multilayered; Bad Girl is a helluva music video; The Girlie Show is perfection. The whole Erotica era is dark and edgy, one that I'll always love. 

[Madonna Song, This or That Game!]

Jimmy Jimmy

Justify My Love or Frozen?

[Madonna Song, This or That Game!]

Like It or Not

I'll Remember or Mer Girl?

[Madonna Song, This or That Game!]

Where Life Begins

Papa Don't Preach or Music? 

[so.. Hung Up On Tokishca is the new Candyshop or Bitch I'm Madonna]

I'd say it's her desperate plea for attention, much like a personal ad. Here's an example:

"SWF with T&A seeking BBC from the NBA."

[Madonna Song, This or That Game!]

Beautiful Stranger

Everybody or Gambler?

[New FEL Theme]

I love it! It has a much more light-hearted and upbeat feel to it. 

[Madonna Song, This or That Game!]

Jump

Hanky Panky or Love Profusion?

[Finally Enough Love: 50 Number Ones]

16 hours ago, musicinferno said:

It's such a task getting through disc 3 in my car - most of the mixes are horrid. 

I agree. I'm really very impressed with discs one and two, but the third? I don't think so! 

[Madonna Song, This or That Game!]

You'll See

Lucky Star or Dress You Up?

[Madonna Song, This or That Game!]

Easy Ride

Bye Bye Baby or Die Another Day?

[Madonna Song, This or That Game!]

Erotic

Express Yourself or Human Nature?

[Madonna Song, This or That Game!]

La Isla Bonita

Spanish Eyes or Nothing Really Matters?

[Music Vs. American Life (The battle of Mirwais)]

It's a tough choice, but I would have to choose Music.

As someone else mentioned, American Life is a more cohesive album, but it's really Music that has captured my interest over the years. There's a variety on the Music album that is really cool: Madge can go from something danceable like Music or Impressive Instant, to something deep like Paradise (Not for Me) or Gone, all in one album. The range of her songwriting skills, I think, is underrated. Also Music has some really kickass music videos!

[Madonna Song, This or That Game!]

Bedtime Story

Like a Virgin or Skin?

[Rocco Ritchie for VOGUE Hong Kong Sep/2022]

Am I the only one who is sick of hearing about Madge's children? Ugh. 

[Madonna Song, This or That Game!]

Borderline

American Pie or Candy Shop?

[Rina Sawayama ’s "Send My Love to John" sampled "X-Static Process" ?]