Madonna Song, This or That Game!

[Donna 16,448]

Vogue  (but I'd love some 'Hanky Panky'...LOL)

Erotica or S.E.X.?

[Madant 921]

LOL

Erotica

Deeper and Deeper (Shep's Classic 12") or Deeper and Deeper (David's Classic 12")?

[Donna 16,448]

Shep's Classic 12"

You Must Love Me or Masterpiece?

[Madant 921]

Masterpiece

Keep It Together (12'' Remix) or Keep It Together (12'' Mix)?

[Donna 16,448]

Tough one.  Love both equally.  But I'll go with 12" Remix

Like A Prayer (SST) or Like A Prayer (RIT) ?

[Madant 921]

Yeah, also, isn't it uncanny how they didn't bother to come up with more distinct and memorable titles for the remixes up until the Bedtime Story era, I guess?

Like a Prayer (RIT)

Erotica (WO 12''') or I'll Remember (Guerilla Beach Mix)?

[Donna 16,448]

Well, she was one of the few who really brought remixes to the forefront and as time went on, her remixed songs became vastly different from the original song than the earlier mixes.

Erotica (WO 12"")

True Blue (The Color Mix) or True Blue (The Remix/Edit)?

[Madant 921]

Yeah, and that's what so special about M's remixes! Sometimes, it's like a totally different song!

True Blue (The Color Mix)

Frozen (Meltdown Mix - Long Version) or Frozen (Widescreen Mix)?

 

 

[Donna 16,448]

Another toughie.  I'm going to say Widescreen Mix gets my vote today.

Her playing electric guitar or acoustic?

[Madant 921]

Electric guitar

Die Another Day (Dirty Vegas Main Mix) or Die Another Day (Thee RetroLectro Mix)?

[Donna 16,448]

Die Another Day (Dirty Vegas Main Mix)

I'll Surrender Dear (film performance) or Sooner or Later (film performance)?

[Madant 921]

I'll Surrender Dear

Crazy for You or Gambler?

[Donna 16,448]

Crazy For You

I'll Remember or Time Stood Still?

[Madant 921]

I'll Remember

Into the Groove (Original Version) or Into the Groove (You Can Dance Remix - Unmixed)?

[Donna 16,448]

ITG (Original Version) but the YCD is really great.

Like A Prayer Brunette curly hair or Nothing Really Matters Dark Brown straight hair?

[Madant 921]

LAP (though I looove the NRM video look, too)

Nothing Really Matters (Vikram) or Nothing Really Matters (Kruder & Dorfmeister)?

[Donna 16,448]

Just now, Madant said:

LAP (though I looove the NRM video look, too)

Nothing Really Matters (Vikram) or Nothing Really Matters (Kruder & Dorfmeister)?

Same... both looks are great, but she looks so natural and more radiant in LAP. 

I'm not a big fan of the NRM mixes, but they are far better than POG remixes.  So I'll go with:

NRM (Vikram)

 

Sing a Duet with Kylie or Sing a Duet with Lady Gaga?

 

[Madant 921]

Yeah, her hair looked more natural in the LAP video, and she looks so good when going dark-haired 

Kylie

Living for Love (THRILL Remix) or Ghosttown (THRILL Remix)?

[Donna 16,448]

Not a fan of either, but Ghosttown's mix is better.

Hey You (Live) or Imagine (Live)?

[Drum Dub 1,885]

Imagine 

Shanti/Ashtangi or Runaway Lover?

[Ayham 5,483]

Runaway Lover

Frozen or Fighting Spirit?

[Donna 16,448]

Frozen

Living For Love or Bitch I'm Madonna?

[Ayham 5,483]

Bitch I’m Madonna

Frozen or Like A Prayer?

[Voguerista 11,816]

Like A Prayer

Her look in the Like A Prayer video or her look in the Celebration video? 

[Donna 16,448]

Like A Prayer

Vogue or Express Yourself?