Beautiful Stranger Vs. Amazing

[Headless.Headphones 728]

I think I might know how this will end but anyone's guess - this soundtrack cut and it's doppelgangar. And go!

[Yung Rapunxel 2,186]

Beautiful Stranger

 

I like Amazing but it sounds like a cheaper emulation of Beautiful Stranger

[Enrico 16,030]

Beautiful Stranger is really M at her best. Nice lyrics, awesome video (she looks so sexy in it), great sound and the flute at the end is fantastic.

[Luca 85]

I personally prefer Amazing.

It's more "elaborate", and a lot more "orbit-ish".    I really love the mood of that song, a little bit nostalgic. It's the "non-acoustic" version of I Deserve It (such a wonderful song! ) .

 

I never really understood Beautiful Stranger. I find it noisy, useless and silly, although it works perfect live (it could still be a perfect song for an encore... in fact if you turn the Drowned World Tour upside down, it has an excellent conclusion  ).

[Holy_Water 209]

Amazing 

[Headless.Headphones 728]

I've never personally been one or the other until probably that fan made but official long version of Beautiful Stranger; it kind of was a perfect book ends and it made sense now if that makes sense.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Madame Madonna 4,108]

amazing

[Headless.Headphones 728]

The underdog has half of the votes so that's awesome lol. (well half of BS's)

[Stevo 6,451]

There is no contest. Beautiful Stranger all the way baby! 😎ðŸ˜

[madgefan 10,202]

AMAZING 

[tifenn 99]

Amazing too !

[angelamanda623 329]

Okay, this poll WAS a bit difficult for me; personally, I am not a fan of either one of these songs.  In fact, I had to read all of your reviews before I even voted, to get a clear picture which I never have to do.  

 

They do sound alike (as some of you have already mentioned), both with like this vibe that I really cannot stand or explain.  But--again--my daughter likes "Beautiful Stranger" a bit, so it got the vote.  

[geert 3,192]

Beautiful Stranger

[Daniciccone10 32]

Beautiful stranger

[Scottyx 9,069]

I always considered them a part 1 and part 2 of the same song lol

 

For me, Beautiful Stranger, but only because of the Calderone mixes - club days of old ;)

[davidaniston 0]

You should have included "I'm A sinner"

[Headless.Headphones 728]

You should have included "I'm A sinner"

 

No that is being left for the Ray of Light vs. I'm a Sinner poll. 

[ziggy 1]

This is such an obvious no-brainer. Amazing is basically a lamer version of BS.