Game: + and - of Madonna Songs

[MeantToBeIconic 998]

So this is a game I played over on Exhale and I thought you'd all enjoy it!

 

So here's how it goes:

 

Let's say the song is "Music"

 

I will then say what are (in my opinion) one positive and one negative about the song, such as

 

Positive: The synths at the end are awesomely folktronica   

 

Negative: I think the intro from the extended demo was better than the album intro 

 

Then I provide a song: Candy Shop

 

Then the next person says the negatives and positives, offers the next song, and repeat!

 

You are allowed to do unreleased, demo/tour versions, and officials, but I would try to stay away from remixes.

Edited April 4, 2015 by MeantToBeIconic (see edit history)

[devilpray 2,387]

i want to play what do i win

[MeantToBeIconic 998]

i want to play what do i win

 

 

The joy of knowing you were the first poster! 

[devilpray 2,387]

The joy of knowing you were the first poster! 

 

 

yaaaas bow down bitches the king is here

[MeantToBeIconic 998]

So the first song is going to be

 

 

THE OPENING TRACK FOR HARD CANDY

 

CANDY SHOP

[devilpray 2,387]

positive: the synths in the chorus

 

negative: the beat is way too repetitive

 

 

the next song is Pray for Spanish Eyes!

[MeantToBeIconic 998]

positive: the synths in the chorus

 

negative: the beat is way too repetitive

 

You forgot to name the next song

[devilpray 2,387]

You forgot to name the next song

 oops, just fixed that!

[MeantToBeIconic 998]

positive: the synths in the chorus

 

negative: the beat is way too repetitive

 

 

the next song is Pray for Spanish Eyes!

Hold Up. Let me listen to it... 

 

Positive: "If there is a Christ... He'll come tonight..." Beautiful chorus.

 

Positive 2: I LOVE the rasp in the chorus.

 

Negative: Mmm... the one random line of the Spanish guy 

 

 

Next is Jump!

[Zeee3499 18]

Hold Up. Let me listen to it... Positive: "If there is a Christ... He'll come tonight..." Beautiful chorus.Positive 2: I LOVE the rasp in the chorus.Negative: Mmm... the one random line of the Spanish guy :Madonna002:Next is Jump!

There is nothing negative about Jump how could you even do that.

[Redha DBL 7,350]

Hold Up. Let me listen to it... 

 

Positive: "If there is a Christ... He'll come tonight..." Beautiful chorus.

 

Positive 2: I LOVE the rasp in the chorus.

 

Negative: Mmm... the one random line of the Spanish guy 

 

 

Next is Jump!

 

JUMP:

 

Positive : The bassline

 

Negative : The chorus could be catchier

 

next : Don't Tell Me

[devilpray 2,387]

Don't Tell Me

 

Positive: The strings on the last part of the song

 

Negative: Some synths are kinda tacky

 

Next: Rain

[vanjaborrderline 103]

rain.. positive - lyrics,production,everything

 

negative - in the video there are lot of asian people. I don't enjoy them. they read mind

 

next song - LOOK OF LOVE

[devilpray 2,387]

that was weirdly racist 

[unapologeticheart 872]

LOOK OF LOVE

Positives: Great lyrics, M's tone sounds great, It was actually performed live

Negatives: Those bells at the beginning and throughout the song sound kinda cheap

 

 

Next song : Dear Jessie

[MechanicalDNA 279]

dear jessie

positive:  the violin transition to oh father

negative: be a track of like a prayer 

 

next: Paradise (Not For Me)

[Jorick 1,453]

Paradijselijke (Not for Me)Positive: one of Madonna 's gems, should have been a single. Negative: album version is too long, like the drowned world tour edit version way better. Next up: Bad Girl

[Halex 1,609]

Bad Girl :

 

Positive : awesome vocals and lyrics

 

Negative : deserved more good remixes

 

Next up : Skin

[unapologeticheart 872]

Skin

 

Positives: Perfect on every level, awesome vocals and lyrics, flaw-free production, I LOVE the sample near the end

Negative: it's so underrated :1f614:

 

Next: She's not Me

[devilpray 2,387]

She's not Me

 

Positive: when the beat goes crazy and she's saying never will be

Negative: Pharrell

 

Next: I Remember

[mikenmark 422]

I'll remember

 

Positive:William Orbit's bleepy bloopy bits

Negative:William Orbit's bleepy bloopy bits

 

Next: Easy Ride

[fierysadness 13]

"Easy Ride"

Positive: The gorgeous strings used throughout the song

Negative: Mirwais' signature choppy editing

 

Next: "To Have and Not to Hold"

[MeantToBeIconic 998]

To Have and Not to Hold

 

Positive: Madonna's vocals are great on the track. They're just gorgeous.

 

Negative: Of all the tracks on Ray of Light, I think this one is the most forgettable

 

 

Next is Live to Tell (Confessions Tour Studio Version)

[madgefan 10,150]

Live to Tell (Confessions Tour Studio Version)

 

Positive: Shocking performance that caught EVERYBODY's attention in 2006.

Negative: The performance is somewhat ambiguous and that's not good if you're using strong Christian imagery, the black kids message got lost in some way...

 

Next is Ghosttown...

[devilpray 2,387]

Ghosttown

 

Positive: The chorus and the vocal melody are flawless

 

Negative: the white noise before the first verse

 

next: Think of Me