Pick that extra single

[Headless.Headphones 727]

Now remembering Nothing Fails was a failed single I will go with Nobody Knows Me instead.   Also Physical Attraction guys? maybe if they cut like 5 mins it's so long.

[RUADJAI 14,963]

1. Physical Attraction

2. Pretender

3. Where's the Party (obviously)

4. Till Death Do Us Part

5. Thief of Hearts

6. Love Tried to Welcome Me

7. Candy Perfume Girl

8. Impressive Instant and Paradise Not for Me

9. Easy Ride

10. Future Lovers

11. Heartbeat

12. Love Spent and Gang Bang

13. Holy Water

[dylanlioncourt 5,780]

Madonna - Physical Attraction

Like a Virgin - StayTrue Blue - Where's The PartyLike a Prayer - Till Death Do Us PartErotica - WordsBedtime Stories - Love Tried To Welcome MeRay of Light - SkinMusic - Paradise (Not For Me)American Life - Intervention/Nobody Knows MeConfessions - Future LoversHard Candy - Devil Wouldn't Recognize YouMDNA - Love SpentRebel Heart - HeartBreakCity

[Dazedmadonna 16,423]

Now remembering Nothing Fails was a failed single I will go with Nobody Knows Me instead.   Also Physical Attraction guys? maybe if they cut like 5 mins it's so long.

Holiday is literally 6 minutes, and is a single. Radio Edits happen when there's a single that needs to be sent to radios, and even Physical Attraction which served as a b-side on various 7" and 12" got Fade Edits for U.K., Philippines, Brazil and more.

[madbella 596]

Madonna = I know it

 

Like a virgin = Over and over (Not only Italy)

 

True blue = Where´s the party?

 

Like a prayer = Till death do us part

 

Erotica = Thief of hearts

 

Bedtime stories = Inside of me

 

Ray of light = Candy perfume girl

 

Music = Impressive instant

 

American life = Im so stupid

 

Confessions on a dance floor = Isaac

 

Hard candy = Devil wouldnt recognize you

 

MDNA = Love spent

 

Rebel Heart = Hold tight 

[skyfitswim 906]

Madonna: think of me

Like A Virgin: Over And Over 

True Blue: Where's The Party

Who's That Girl: Can't Stop

Like A Prayer: (Pray For) Spanish Eyes

I'm Breathless: now i following you (part 2) 

Erotica: thief of hearts 

Bedtime Stories: sanctuary 

Ray Of Light: Skin or sky fits heaven 

the best thing : time stood still !! 

Music: Impressive Instant 

American Life: Nobody Knows Me

Confessions On A Dance Floor: Future Lovers or forbidden love 

Hard Candy: incredible or she is not me 

celebration : broken

MDNA: gang bang or addicted 

Rebel Heart: inside out or hold tight 

[madgefan 10,149]

It's funny because most of the songs you've listed were the chosen b-sides to accompany the official singles. The only albums I would have picked more singles from are her latest:

 

Hard Candy Beat Goes On or She's Not Me

MDNA Gang Bang or Love Spent

Rebel Heart Rebel Heart, Unapologetic Bitch or Addicted

[wtg1987 10,167]

Thought it would be cool to add an unreleased b-side too just to make fans buy it

 

1 - Physical Attraction b/w Aint No Big Deal

2- Over & Over b/w Warning Signs( )  )

3 - Where's The Party b/w Spotlight(True Blue Demo)

4 - Spanish Eyes b/w Love Attack

5 - Back In Business(Dont know any unreleased songs from this era ? Maybe add First is A Kiss as LAP demo ? )

6 - Words b/w Shame or maybe the Actions Speak Louder Than Words demo ?

7 - I'd Rather Be Your Lover b/w Love Won't Wait

8 - Rainbow High(Dont know any unreleased tracks from this era so maybe add Cant Forget ? )

9 - Swim b/w Like A Flower

10 - I Deserve It b/w La Pettite Jeune Fille

11- Intervention b/w Cant You See My Mind(Lol)

12 - Fighting Spirit b/w Triggering

13 - Devil Wouldnt Recognise You b/w Latte

14 - Falling Free b/w ????

15 - Joan Of Arc b/w Queen

[AModSquad 514]

1. Think of Me

2. Over and Over

3. Where's The Party

4. Spanish Eyes

5. Thief of Hearts

6. Survival

7. Sky Fits Heaven

8. Impressive Instant

9. Nobody Knows Me

10. Future Lovers

11. Beat Goes On

12. I'm Addicted

13. HeartbreakCity

[Rory 856]

Madonna: Physical Attraction

Like a Virgin: Pretender

True Blue: (all good singles released--plus Where's the Party on You Can Dance)

Like a Pryer: (all good singles released/remixed--plus Supernatural)

I'm Breathless: He's A Man

Erotica: Secret Garden (club remixes)

Bedtime Stories: Sanctuary (club remixes)

Evita: Another Suitcase in Another Hall

Ray of Light: Skin

Music: Nobody's Perfect

American Life: Easy Ride

Confessions: Like It or Not

Hard Candy: She's Not Me

MDNA: I'm A Sinner

Rebel Heart: Inside Out

[mr00mister 893]

Madonna: Think Of Me

Like A Virgin: Over And Over

True Blue: Love Makes The World Go Round

Like A Prayer: Promise To Try

Erotica: Why Is It So Hard?

Bedtime Stories: Survival

Ray Of Light: Skin

Music: Impressive Instant

American Life: Intervention

Confessions On A Dance Floor: Push

Hard Candy: Beat Goes On

MDNA: Falling Free

Rebel Heart: Devil Pray

[madgefan 10,149]

Thought it would be cool to add an unreleased b-side too just to make fans buy it

 

5 - Back In Business(Dont know any unreleased songs from this era ? Maybe add First is A Kiss as LAP demo ? )

 

 

I think More was the b-side of Hanky Panky 

[je5u5 1,108]

01 A proper release for "Physical Attraction"

02 Over and Over

03 Where's the Party

04 Till Death Do Us Part

05 Waiting

06 Survival

07 Skin

08 Impressive Instant

09 Nobody Knows Me

10 Forbidden Love

11 Beat Goes On

12 I'm a Dick Ted

13 Unapologetic Bitch

[bstranger 469]

1. Physical Attraction

 

2. Over and Over

 

3. Where's The Party

 

4. Spanish Eyes

 

5. Why's It So Hard

 

6. Love tried to welcome me

 

7. Sky Fits Heaven

 

8. Impressive Instant

 

9. Mother and Father

 

10. Future Lovers

 

11. Beat Goes On

 

12. Love Spent

 

13. Rebel Heart

 

[tasteinmen 295]

1. Physical Attraction (edit)

2. Over & Over

3. Where's the Party

4. Spanish Eyes

5. Thief of Hearts

6. Survival

7. Skin

8. Impressive Instant

9. Nobody Knows Me

10. Forbidden Love

11. The Beat Goes On

12. Love Spent

13. Iconic

[kanto_kid 35]

my choices.. 

 

Madonna: Physical Attraction

Like A Virgin: Pretender

True Blue: White Heat

Like a Prayer: Promise To Try

I'm Breathless: Back In Business

Erotica: Thief of Hearts

Bedtime Stories: I'd Rather Be Your Lover

Ray of Light: Sky Fits Heaven

Music: Gone

American Life: Easy Ride

Confessions on a Dance Floor: Forbidden Love

Hard Candy: Devil Wouldn't Recognize You

MDNA: Love Spent

Rebel Heart: Body Shop

[Turuncan 737]

I will choose according to single-worthiness, and add my favorite album track in brackets if they are not the same songs.

 

Madonna: 'Physical Attraction'

Like a Virgin: 'Over and Over' ('Stay')

True Blue: 'Where's the Party?' ('White Heat' or 'Jimmy Jimmy')

Like a Prayer: 'Till Death Do Us Part'

I'm Breathless: 'Sooner or Later' ('He's a Man')

Erotica: 'Why's It So Hard?'

Bedtime Stories: 'Forbidden Love' or 'Survival'

Evita: 'Buenos Aires' ('I'd Be Surprisingly Good for You')

Ray of Light: 'Skin'

Music: 'Paradise (Not for Me)'

American Life: 'Nobody Knows Me' ('Intervention')

Confessions on a Dance Floor: 'Isaac' ('Future Lovers')

Hard Candy: Devil Wouldn't Recognize You ('Voices')

MDNA: 'Love Spent'

Rebel Heart: 'Messiah'

[Enrico 15,823]

1. Ain't no big deal (it was left out at the final stages)

2. Stay

3. Where's the party (but the 5 are enough)

4. Spanish eyes

5. He's a man

6. Waiting

7. Survival

8. Swim

9. Nobody's perfect

10. Nobody knows me

11. Forbidden love

12. She's not me

13. Masterpiece

14. Unapologetic Bitch & Rebel Heart

[Esteban 125]

Madonna: "Physical Attraction"

Like A Virgin: "Love Don't Live Here Anymore" 

True Blue: "Where's the Party?"

Like A Prayer: "Promise To Try"

I'm Breathless: "Sooner Or Later"

Erotica: "Secret Garden"

Bedtime Stories: "Love Tried to Welcome Me"

Ray Of Light: "Sky Fits Heaven" (alternative single: "Mer Girl", imagine a proper Bedtime Story-like video?!)

Music: "Impressive Instant" (proper full official worldwide single with video)

American Life: "X-Static Process"

Confessions On A Dance Floor: "Future Lovers"

Hard Candy: "Beat Goes On"

MDNA: AA single "I'm Addicted/ I'm A Sinner"

Rebel Heart: Another AA single "Devil Pray/Body Shop"

[gafuller 1,653]

Madonna/Like A Virgin/True Blue: I'd leave these alone. The only things I'd wish we'd had from these eras was a music video to Dress You Up and Angel.

 

Like A Prayer: Love Song. I hate but love this song. It's so clunky but come on, it was a chance to have Primce and her together. Too bad he didn't want to do it.

 

Erotica: I'd leave this one aswell. Five was enough and Bye Bye Baby didn't carry aswell as the final single as it was, despite loving it myself.

 

Bedtime Story: I'd Rather Be Your Lover (Tupac preferably). Could've been another career show stopper, daring to be dangerous.

 

Ray of Light: Shanti/Ashangti. Being that she used it for music awards performance and really could've had a beautiful music video of Hindu culture.

 

Music: Impressive Instance

 

American Life: Nobody Knows Me

 

Confessions: Odd decisions honestly but I'd have chosen I Love New York here, and gave it an awesome rocking choreographed music video, piggy backing off of Sorry, making a trilogy. Also would have given Get Together a proper music video.

 

Hard Candy: Candy Shop- making the music video a fun little tour of her "candy shop". Would've been great to coincide with the start of Sticky and Sweet. I'd also pick She's No Me as maybe the third single.

 

MDNA: I'm Addicted as the first single, month or so before Super Bowl.

 

Rebel Heart: I've got three singles to put here, breaking where I've usually kept the rest of the albums at five singles. In fact let me just lay out the whole schedule for this albums singles. Ghosttown should have been released as the first single and she should not have put any other songs up just because of the leaks. Ghosttown would have been great for the winter. Living for Love released as intended on Valentine's. B*tch I'm Madonna bumped up to Ghosttowns original release date. Devil Oray released inJune. Then Unappolgetic B to coincide with Rebel Heart Tour and then Rebel Heart released as the Tour either wraps up or when it premiers on TV for the first time.

[PlayPause 2,684]

Madonna : I Know It

 

Like a Virgin : Over and Over

 

True Blue : Shoo-Bee-Doo

 

Like a Prayer : Love Song

 

Erotica : Why's It So Hard

 

Bedtime Stories : I'd Rather Be Your Lover

 

Ray of Light : Swim

 

Music : Nobody's Perfect

 

American Life : Nobody Knows Me

 

Confessions on a Dance Floor : Let It Will Be

 

Hard Candy : Beat Goes On

 

MDNA : I'm Addicted

 

Rebel Heart : Illuminati

[skyfitswim 906]

01 Physical Attraction

02 over and over 

03 Where's The Party

04 Spanish Eyes

05 Thief Of Hearts

06 sancuary

07 Sky Fits Heaven

08 time stood still

09 impressive instant

10 nobody knows me 

12 Forbidden Love

11 devil would recognize you

13 addicted

14 inside out 

[Turuncan 737]

01 Physical Attraction

02 over and over 

03 Where's The Party

04 Spanish Eyes

05 Thief Of Hearts

06 sancuary

07 Sky Fits Heaven

08 time stood still

09 impressive instant

10 nobody knows me 

12 Forbidden Love

11 devil would recognize you

13 addicted

14 inside out 

 

You mean 'I'm Addicted'?

[Inco 9,848]

Madonna: Physical Attraction

Like A Virgin: Stay

True Blue: Where's The Party

Who's That Girl: Can't Stop

You Can Dance: Spotlight

Like A Prayer: Spanish Eyes

I'm Breathless: Sooner Or Later

Erotica: Why's It So Hard

Bedtime Stories: (hard one) Forbidden Love

Something To Remember: I Want You

Evita: Lament

Ray Of Light: (hard one) Skin

Music: I Deserve It

American Life: (hard one) Easy Ride

Remixed & Revisited: Your Honesty

Confessions On A Dance Floor: Let It Will Be

Hard Candy: Devil Wouldn't Recognize You

Celebration: It's So Cool

MDNA: Beautiful Killer

Rebel Heart: Heartbreak City

[Turuncan 737]

Who's That Girl: Can't Stop

 

 

I also wish 'The Look of Love' had received full-single treatment.