Least favorite album

[Rebel 915]

- Madame X

- MDNA

[Tony Fortin 1,788]

HARD CANDY except Miles Away

MDNA is around the corner

[Aiwa08 16,217]

8 hours ago, Fabiolous said:

MDNA wins this hands down, like come on

No. MDNA won't win this because it has amazing songs. Wake up.

My vote: Rebel Heart (I love the demo version but not the final version).

[Chris 1,023]

i never touch MDNA, Hard Candy or Ray of Light.

[Leona Helmsley 9,418]

9 minutes ago, Chris said:

i never touch MDNA, Hard Candy or Ray of Light.

nooooooooooooo!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Leona Helmsley 9,418]

@Chris really? mdna and hard Candy are my fav.....

[Would You Like To Try 8,346]

Otto Album

[WokeUpInMedellin 1,556]

MDNA is such a good album wtf.

My least favorite is Rebel Heart. God some of those songs sound so beneath her

[Chris 1,023]

42 minutes ago, dave2290 said:

@Chris really? mdna and hard Candy are my fav.....

pretty much, yes.

https://www.last.fm/user/Christopher-Roy/library/music/Madonna/+albums

[Frankito 185]

MDNA

[Frankito 185]

MDNA

[Cyberraga 662]

Rebel Heart

I just don't know what it is about. It's said that the album is about rebelious and romantic sides of Madonna, but she's romantic and rebelious all over her catalogue so I don't really undestand its existence.

[TOpher 898]

It’s a hard toss up between Madame X and MDNA. I did listen to MDNA more than MX when it came out so I guess MX 🤷‍♂️

[MDNA22 1,195]

Would have to go with Rebel Heart, - it's such a mess. The final album mixes were worse than the demos, some of the vocals are grating, too many tracks, more mediocre and bad tracks on there than good ones, and for the most part doesn't sound like any of it was written by Madonna and just an album made and put out to meet contractual obligations. The officially commissioned remixes for the singles were poor.

Listening to the demo's there was alot of promise in enough of the tracks to make a really good album with some more work and better production and narrowing the track listing down to the best 10 tracks only. I do think if she had made the record while with Warners we would have got a much better final album - less tracks, better track selection and much better versions and better choice of singles and higher standard of remixes. Maybe the leaks meant decisions on final track listing and mixes got rushed and changed just to make them different to the leaked versions for the sake of it? The mastering is not great too with some really grating shrill vocals (living for love, unapologetic bitch etc) and bad overdubs on some tracks (Graffiti Heart). Just as an album is hard to connect to in the same way as her other albums 

[MDNA22 1,195]

Just now, MDNA22 said:

Would have to go with Rebel Heart, - it's such a mess. The final album mixes were worse than the demos, some of the vocals are grating, too many tracks, more mediocre and bad tracks on there than good ones, and for the most part doesn't sound like any of it was written by Madonna and just an album made and put out to meet contractual obligations. The officially commissioned remixes for the singles were poor.

Listening to the demo's there was alot of promise in enough of the tracks to make a really good album with some more work and better production and narrowing the track listing down to the best 10 tracks only. I do think if she had made the record while with Warners we would have got a much better final album - less tracks, better track selection and much better versions and better choice of singles and higher standard of remixes. Maybe the leaks meant decisions on final track listing and mixes got rushed and changed just to make them different to the leaked versions for the sake of it? The mastering is not great too with some really grating shrill vocals (living for love, unapologetic bitch etc) and bad overdubs on some tracks (Graffiti Heart). Just as an album is hard to connect to in the same way as her other albums 

 

[WokeUpInMedellin 1,556]

3 hours ago, MDNA22 said:

Would have to go with Rebel Heart, - it's such a mess. The final album mixes were worse than the demos, some of the vocals are grating, too many tracks, more mediocre and bad tracks on there than good ones, and for the most part doesn't sound like any of it was written by Madonna and just an album made and put out to meet contractual obligations. The officially commissioned remixes for the singles were poor.

Listening to the demo's there was alot of promise in enough of the tracks to make a really good album with some more work and better production and narrowing the track listing down to the best 10 tracks only. I do think if she had made the record while with Warners we would have got a much better final album - less tracks, better track selection and much better versions and better choice of singles and higher standard of remixes. Maybe the leaks meant decisions on final track listing and mixes got rushed and changed just to make them different to the leaked versions for the sake of it? The mastering is not great too with some really grating shrill vocals (living for love, unapologetic bitch etc) and bad overdubs on some tracks (Graffiti Heart). Just as an album is hard to connect to in the same way as her other albums 

Agreed, good analysis

[Unruhe 1,431]

Music

[stefo 6,387]

HARD CANDY, definitely it's the less M album of them all, for the major part she is recognizable only by her voice imo.

[Honey Little 3,996]

Confessions on a Dancefloor 

[Fernando 427]

Bedtime stories , hard candy

[FreshPrince 10]

Confessions, but Get Together you're my sweet child.

[adirondak 1,588]

Can’t believe how many people don’t like Rebel heart.  I don’t think it’s her best album, but I also don’t think it’s anywhere near her worst. So many great songs on there and a few duds. 

[scamper 1,998]

Ray of light. Great in 1998, Boring now

[jemboy1973 663]

Madame X, I have tried repeatedly to see if I can like it but no. even the songs I could like seem ruined. Like God Control Into? 

Saying that I never liked American Life when it came out and only now have just started to warm to it. 

[Drownedboy 1,676]

I agree about Rebel Heart analysis; but at least there were many decent tracks and it´s like she putted some care on some of the singing parts you know? She looked good, still dance quite a bit through the era, had many amazing videos, looked gorgeous and sung quite good on the Tour, which had many amazing moments. For me that was the last time Madonna was Madonna, well, maybe till the Celebration tour.

Madame x it´s like she wen´t too far with the x factor cause you don´t recongise her voice on many tracks, no effort on singing, too long of an album, too many bad songs, bad production, bad look, strange concept overall, Eurovision, the woke message,  the eye patch, the tour cancelation, the hip, and all the came later: OMG, Im traumatised by this era. I need to preted it never existed. And the only song I can enjoy of it all will be I´ll rise.