Which album should get a sequel?

[Fabiolous 5,491]

Let's be honest, Madonna would never do anything like this. However, Nicki Minaj releasing "Pink Friday 2", a sequel of her 2010 album "Pink Friday", got me thinking. Which album would you choose for a sequel in 2024?

[Fabiolous 5,491]

To be honest, I think Madame X already felt like an American Life 2 with a twist, and Rebel heart like a mid-2010s Erotica 2.

[sara94 2,211]

Ray of Light & Confessions

[Honey Little 3,996]

The first album 

[EgoRod 5,451]

Extended reviews can be interesting. Like PSB did with their collection plus demos, outtakes etc. It gives serious fans something extra to enjoy and gives some deep and info about the conceptualization of an album. A sequel from a creative point of view is something different. The artist evolves and moves away from the space and time when it was making the album. The world changes too and you grow with an artist based on their work. A Confessions two or ROL sequel won't make any sense, it will be reducing the album to just a music style or a fad. Even following that, it will sound dated.

[Pretender1978 996]

2 hours ago, Fabiolous said:

To be honest, I think Madame X already felt like an American Life 2 with a twist, and Rebel heart like a mid-2010s Erotica 2.

Madonna did say in an interview that MX was like AL 2.0 so in a sense we already had one, I defenitely wouldnt mind if it would become a triptyque, but maybe not for another few years

Not sure if I agree with the Erotica RH comparison though, that was such a strong conceptual album about modern relationships, lonelyness and bigotry, RH is just a mess lol, a mess with some great songs on it but a mess nonetheless

[Leona Helmsley 9,418]

confessions and hard candy

[mirtillo 1,842]

Something To Remember

[Prayer 14,375]

Kinda unrelated but, when I became a fan in 1998, it seemed weird that she got a "Like A Prayer" only two albums after having a "Like A Virgin". A friend of mine told me "all her songs are Like A something?" 

[steady75 9,570]

Like A Prayer. 
It’s the most personal and real album.

I think the Like A Trilogy will come late day. When all her kids are left home and maybe her father passes she’ll have some new perspectives on that life cycle from her youth to her old age. A full circle moment. 

[Ayham 5,483]

None…

 

[WeYo 672]

24 minutes ago, Ayham said:

None…

 

+1

[animalinstinct 2,048]

Confessions

[Leona Helmsley 9,418]

@animalinstinct like me! do you imagine? another Hung up? or sorry or let it will be.... or isaac who is wonderful..... wow

[Nowheretohide 249]

Something to remember2

[pawn_shop_blues 576]

None. 

[PHIL 260]

EROTICA

being mother, older, still sexual creature with all it's elements, desires, feelings

 

[Aiwa08 16,217]

I always wanted "True Blue 2", "Like A Prayer 2", "Erotica 2", "Confessions 2", and "MDNA 2". But that bitch never fulfilled my wishes... Maybe it's the best decision

[lap 1,495]

Ray of Light

Confessions (not my favorite, but it was a huge global success)

And although it could be dated by now, I would love Like a Prayer part 2

 

[Leona Helmsley 9,418]

9 minutes ago, lap said:

Ray of Light

Confessions (not my favorite, but it was a huge global success)

And although it could be dated by now, I would love Like a Prayer part 2

 

curious to have another like a prayer song....  something so iconic and perfect....

[gbiluis 95]

She should work again with Stuart Price, Confessions 2

[animalinstinct 2,048]

23 minutes ago, gbiluis said:

She should work again with Stuart Price, Confessions 2

That’s what I want too.
I mean, if she can work with William Orbit and Mirwais again, why not Stuart next. 

[scamper 1,998]

8 hours ago, Prayer said:

Kinda unrelated but, when I became a fan in 1998, it seemed weird that she got a "Like A Prayer" only two albums after having a "Like A Virgin". A friend of mine told me "all her songs are Like A something?" 

Yeah, lot of people I know used to say that... Even I remember a 1997 article saying "Madonna is working in her next album... A new "Like a virgin" or a new "Like a prayer" is coming?

Imagine that "Ray of light" was called "Like a flower"??? :P

[Aiwa08 16,217]

3 hours ago, dave2290 said:

curious to have another like a prayer song....  something so iconic and perfect....

Oh, have you forgotten how many fans referred to "Nothing Fails" as "Like A Prayer 2" for months in 2003?

 It was exhausting. 

[Pootz333 2,691]

The album that deserved this, not so much as a proper seperate sequel, but an expansion, was ROL. And she was onto that with the Veronica Electronica idea. I really wish that would have happened. Almost all of the remixes from that era have aged extremely well. Would have loved to hear some of the other none singles get reworked. And while we're at it, it really deserved to be the first full visual pop album.